# Gavin Andresen
# 2010-08-06 19:36:12
# https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=723.msg7940#msg7940

@s{quotedtext}
@s{quotedtext}
Interesting idea. @p{par}

So, lets see, I create a transaction to pay you (say) 100 of my newly minted bitcoins. @p{par}

That'll be a transaction with two 50BTC TxIns (signed by me, pointing to two mature GENERATE transactions somewhere in the block chain) and one 100BTC TxOuts. @p{par}

You want to make sure I haven't double-spent those TxIns, so instead of flooding the network with that transaction you find the hash of the two GENERATE transactions and send two queries down into the DHT network:  "Hey, here's a transaction, tell me if it is valid."  They say "yup", and then... what?  Include it in any blocks they're lucky enough to generate?  Broadcast it to everybody (which'd be no better than the current scheme) or some subset of the DHT network (what subset?)? @p{par}

How do you know that you won't get a different answer to "is this transaction valid" if you ask again in 10 minutes when the network topology might have changed? @p{par}

I don't know much about DHT networks and how they manage to keep reliable information when nodes may be coming and going (or buggy or malicious).  How would it work? @p{par}