This sub-document describes,page by page, how we identified the parags breaks in the SPS, and what are their properties.
For each page below there is a table that gives the attributes of the stars on that page, whith the following columns:
| SNN: the star serial number in the page, from S01
|
| CORE: type of the star's core, drawn in normal ink. Either of:
| "no": no core.
| "dot": single dot.
| "ring": ring with blank interior (none in the SPS).
| "--": cannot tell type be determined because of opaque paint.
|
| PAINT: kind of paint job aplied to the star:
| "no": unpainted.
| "splot": a round spot contained in the body of the star.
| "grub": for irregular and gritty smear of paint
| "fill": tries to fill most of the outline, including
| most of the rays.
| "frub": like fill but very rough partial, as for "grub".
|
| COLOR: the color of the paint applied to the star. Either:
| "yel": the semi-transparent yellow of the Light Painter.
| "RED": an opaque dark red paint.
| "WHT": an uncertain semi-transparent off-white paint that may be
| just bleached yel paint.
| "--": not painted.
|
| R: number of rays, including any that becomes a fat tail.
|
| T: presence and type of the "tail", a thin wavy trace
| emanating from the star. Either:
| "-": no tail.
| "1": a single tail,
| "2": a "fat" tail, with two strokes that converge at the end.
|
| OBS: an observation with no embedded blanks, or "--".
For each page below there is also a table that gives the attributes of the parags on that page. Below the table there is a one-line summary with various counts for that page whith the following columns:
| PLOC Locus ID "{fnum}.{lseq}" of parag's head line.
| PNN Sequential parag number in page.
| STR Number of lines with starlets assigned
| SHL Number of short lines
| PUF Number of lines with puffs
| XPF Number of non-head text lines with puffs
| XWL Number of wide linegaps between lines of same parag
| PGH Number of parags = lines marked parag heads
| TXL Number of text lines (excl. titles)
| PPG Number of perfect parags
| PLN Number of text lines in perfect parags
| IPG Number of imperfect parags
| ILN Number of text lines in non-perfect parags
Short lines determine obvious line breaks on f103r before lines 1 (pchedal, aligned with S01), 5 (@pocharal, with S02), 8 (@daroal, S03 at 7.5), 13 (@pomar, S05 at 12.5), 16 (@dshol, aligned with S06), 18 (@polchedy, S07), 21 (@pcham, S08 at 20.6), 24 (@tchoky, aligned with S09), 27 (@qokechy, S10 at 27.2), 30 (@pcholkchdy, S11 at 29.7), 33 (@qokeey, S12 at 32.5), 35 (@qokeear, S13), 37 (@pchedy, S14), 40 (@qokeey, S15), 43 (@tar, S16 at 42.0), 45 (@qokeedy, S17 at 44), 48 (@polarar, S18 at 47.6), and 52 (@pchedal, S19 at 51.8).
These breaks define 17 obvioys parags spanning lines 1-7 and 14-54. They are all technically perfect, even though the starlet of parag 43-44 is aligned with line 42, and that of 45-47 is aligned with line 44.
The obvious parag breaks leave lines 8-12 as an imperfect block with two stars on the margin, S03 and S04. None of those lines is short. Star S03 is 0.2 above line 8 so it should be assigned to line 8. Star S04 (which is smaller than average, with 6 rays only) is 0.2 below line 9, but it is not clear that it belongs there. Other clues must be considered.
Line 9 (@oteeos) starts with with a wide @t.
Line 10 (@daiin) follows a line that ends with @am, and ends 1.5 glyphs before line 9 and resets the right rail.
Line 11 (@dar) comes after a (slightly) wide linegap and a (slightly) short line.
Trusting the widegap and the short line, we assumed a line break before line 11, and assigned S04 to it. However, the block 8-12 should be excluded from sensitive analyses.
PAGE ! SNN ! VPOS ! CORE ! PAINT ! CLR ! R ! T ! OBS
------+-----+------+------+-------+-----+---+---+---------------
f103r | S01 | 01.0 | -- | fill | RED | 7 | - | --
f103r | S02 | 05.0 | no | splot | yel | 8 | - | --
f103r | S03 | 07.8 | dot | splot | yel | 8 | - | --
f103r | S04 | 09.2 | -- | fill | RED | 6 | - | small_star
f103r | S05 | 12.5 | dot | splot | yel | 8 | - | --
f103r | S06 | 16.0 | -- | fill | RED | 8 | - | --
f103r | S07 | 18.0 | no | splot | yel | 7 | - | --
f103r | S08 | 20.7 | no | no | -- | 7 | - | --
f103r | S09 | 24.0 | -- | fill | RED | 7 | - | --
f103r | S10 | 27.2 | no | splot | yel | 7 | - | --
f103r | S11 | 30.0 | dot | no | -- | 8 | - | --
f103r | S12 | 32.6 | -- | fill | RED | 7 | - | --
f103r | S13 | 35.0 | no | splot | yel | 7 | - | --
f103r | S14 | 37.0 | -- | grub | RED | 7 | - | --
f103r | S15 | 40.0 | no | splot | yel | 8 | - | --
f103r | S16 | 42.0 | no | no | -- | 7 | - | --
f103r | S17 | 44.0 | -- | fill | RED | 7 | - | --
f103r | S18 | 48.0 | dot | splot | yel | 8 | - | --
f103r | S19 | 52.0 | dot | splot | yel | 8 | 1 | tail_up
PLOC | PNN | SNN | NL | LRANGE | EVALUATION.
f103r.1 | P01 | S01 | 4 | 1-4 | not perfect: body puffs.
f103r.5 | P02 | S02 | 3 | 5-7 | PERFECT.
f103r.8 | P03 | S03 | 3 | 8-10 | PERFECT.
f103r.11 | P04 | S04 | 2 | 11-12 | PERFECT.
f103r.13 | P05 | S05 | 3 | 13-15 | PERFECT.
f103r.16 | P06 | S06 | 2 | 16-17 | PERFECT.
f103r.18 | P07 | S07 | 3 | 18-20 | PERFECT.
f103r.21 | P08 | S08 | 3 | 21-23 | not perfect: body puffs.
f103r.24 | P09 | S09 | 3 | 24-26 | PERFECT.
f103r.27 | P10 | S10 | 3 | 27-29 | PERFECT.
f103r.30 | P11 | S11 | 3 | 30-32 | PERFECT.
f103r.33 | P12 | S12 | 2 | 33-34 | PERFECT.
f103r.35 | P13 | S13 | 2 | 35-36 | PERFECT.
f103r.37 | P14 | S14 | 3 | 37-39 | PERFECT.
f103r.40 | P15 | S15 | 3 | 40-42 | PERFECT.
f103r.43 | P16 | S16 | 2 | 43-44 | PERFECT.
f103r.45 | P17 | S17 | 3 | 45-47 | PERFECT.
f103r.48 | P18 | S18 | 4 | 48-51 | PERFECT.
f103r.52 | P19 | S19 | 3 | 52-54 | PERFECT.
PAGE | STR | SHL | PUF | XPF | XWL | PGH | TXL | PPG | PLN | IPG | ILN
f103r | 19 | 19 | 14 | 2 | 0 | 19 | 54 | 17 | 47 | 2 | 7
The obvious parag breaks on f103v, defined by short lines, are before lines 1 (@poldar, aligned with star S01), 5 (@pocheor, S02), 9 (@pchalshal, S03 at 8.7), 12 (@salshal, S04 at 11.5), 14 (@teeol, S05), 17 (@qokeedy, S06), 20 (@polchar, S07 at 19.5), 27 (@pcheody, S09), 30 (@pchear, S10), 33 (@yshey, S11), 37 (@olshey, S12), 39 (@polshor, S13), and 43 (@orain, S14 at 42.7).
These obvious breaks define obvious parags spanning lines 1-19 and 27-46, which turn out to be all perfect.
The baseline of line 11 starts bending down and away from that of line 10, so technically that should be considered a wide linegap, suggesting that it is the head of a new parag. However line 11 is less than half-page long. So we ignored that widegap, keeping break before line 12 with starlet S04.
Star S07 seems to be assigned to the obvious parag head line 20, but lines 20-25 of f103v are all long, leaving S08 with no clear assignmsnt.
Star S08 is aligned with line 21 (@t.okain), that starts with an extra-wide @t. Moreover line 21 ends a bit to the left of line 20, resetting the right rail. However, if line 21 were a parag head, then we would have a one-line parag (line 20) followed by a 6-line one (21-26).
The linegap between lines 22 and 23 widens slightly after mid-page, so we should count that as a wide linegap. A parag break before line 23 would resultin two 4-line parags.
There is a puff in line 25. Line 24 is as long as line 23 but shorter than 25 by 2 glyphs. A break before it would result in a 5-line parag (20-24) and a 2-line one (25-26).
We chose the third option, breaking before line 25 and assigning S08 to it. This made both 20-24 and 25-26 into perfect parags. Anyway, the range 20-26 should be excluded from parag-sensitive analyses.
Lines 39-42 of f103v could be a single parag, with starley S13. However, line 40 is half a dozen glyphs short short of the right rail, which would make a break before line 41 to be "almost obvious". On the other hand, there is no star for it, nor any other indicator of parag break.
We chose to put a parag break before line 41, with no starlet. Because of this dubious descision, the block 39-42 should be excluded from sensitive analyses.
PAGE ! SNN ! VPOS ! CORE ! PAINT ! CLR ! R ! T ! OBS
------+-----+------+------+-------+-----+---+---+---------------
f103v | S01 | 01.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | - | --
f103v | S02 | 05.0 | no | splot | yel | 7 | - | --
f103v | S03 | 09.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | - | --
f103v | S04 | 11.5 | dot | splot | yel | 7 | - | --
f103v | S05 | 14.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | - | --
f103v | S06 | 17.0 | dot | splot | yel | 7 | - | --
f103v | S07 | 20.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | - | --
f103v | S08 | 21.0 | dot | splot | yel | 6 | - | small_star
f103v | S09 | 27.0 | -- | splot | RED | 6 | - | small_star
f103v | S10 | 30.0 | dot | splot | yel | 8 | - | --
f103v | S11 | 33.0 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | - | --
f103v | S12 | 37.0 | dot | splot | yel | 8 | - | --
f103v | S13 | 39.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | - | --
f103v | S14 | 43.0 | no | splot | yel | 8 | - | --
PLOC | PNN | SNN | NL | LRANGE | EVALUATION.
f103v.1 | P01 | S01 | 4 | 1-4 | PERFECT.
f103v.5 | P02 | S02 | 4 | 5-8 | PERFECT.
f103v.9 | P03 | S03 | 3 | 9-11 | PERFECT.
f103v.12 | P04 | S04 | 2 | 12-13 | PERFECT.
f103v.14 | P05 | S05 | 3 | 14-16 | PERFECT.
f103v.17 | P06 | S06 | 3 | 17-19 | PERFECT.
f103v.20 | P07 | S07 | 5 | 20-24 | not perfect: internal wide linegap, long tail, normal next linegap.
f103v.25 | P08 | S08 | 2 | 25-26 | not perfect: long prev, normal prev linegap.
f103v.27 | P09 | S09 | 3 | 27-29 | not perfect: body puffs.
f103v.30 | P10 | S10 | 3 | 30-32 | PERFECT.
f103v.33 | P11 | S11 | 4 | 33-36 | PERFECT.
f103v.37 | P12 | S12 | 2 | 37-38 | PERFECT.
f103v.39 | P13 | S13 | 2 | 39-40 | PERFECT.
f103v.41 | P14 | NoS | 2 | 41-42 | not perfect: no starlet.
f103v.43 | P15 | S14 | 4 | 43-46 | PERFECT.
PAGE | STR | SHL | PUF | XPF | XWL | PGH | TXL | PPG | PLN | IPG | ILN
f103v | 14 | 13 | 13 | 1 | 1 | 15 | 46 | 11 | 34 | 4 | 12
The obvious parag breaks on f104r (following short lines) are before lines 1 (@pchdar, with star S01 at line 1.8), 5 (@kchdal, S02 at 4.6), 10 (@tol.chedal, S03 at 9.2), 12 (@tshdol, S04 at 11.7), 16 (@ocheoctey, S05 at 15.5), 19 (@toaiin, S06 at 18.5), 22 (@tshedar, S07 aligned), 27 (@pchedar, S08 at 26.3), 30 (@okeeol, S09 at 30.1), 34 (@pchol, S10 at 33.5), 36 (@psheody, S11 at 35.8), 39 (@pcholor, S12 at 38.7), and 43 (@tsheodl, S13 at 42.2).
The break before line 34 may be questioned because line 33 is only 3 lines shorter than lines 31 and 33. However line 34 starts with a puff, amd lines 32 and 34 are both long, so star S10 is unlikely to refer to line 33 or line 35.
With this decision, all parags on this page turned out to be perfect, and there is no reason to suspect the existence of additional unmarked breaks..
PAGE ! SNN ! VPOS ! CORE ! PAINT ! CLR ! R ! T ! OBS
------+-----+------+------+-------+-----+---+---+---------------
f104r | S01 | 01.9 | -- | frub | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f104r | S02 | 05.0 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f104r | S03 | 09.5 | -- | frub | RED | 8 | 1 | --
f104r | S04 | 11.7 | -- | frub | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f104r | S05 | 15.7 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f104r | S06 | 19.0 | -- | frub | RED | 8 | 1 | --
f104r | S07 | 22.0 | no | splot | yel | 8 | 1 | --
f104r | S08 | 26.2 | -- | frub | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f104r | S09 | 30.3 | dot | splot | yel | 9 | 1 | --
f104r | S10 | 33.5 | -- | splot | RED | 9 | 2 | --
f104r | S11 | 36.0 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f104r | S12 | 38.8 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f104r | S13 | 42.5 | no | splot | yel | 8 | 1 | --
PLOC | PNN | SNN | NL | LRANGE | EVALUATION.
f104r.1 | P01 | S01 | 4 | 1-4 | PERFECT.
f104r.5 | P02 | S02 | 5 | 5-9 | PERFECT.
f104r.10 | P03 | S03 | 2 | 10-11 | PERFECT.
f104r.12 | P04 | S04 | 4 | 12-15 | PERFECT.
f104r.16 | P05 | S05 | 3 | 16-18 | PERFECT.
f104r.19 | P06 | S06 | 3 | 19-21 | PERFECT.
f104r.22 | P07 | S07 | 5 | 22-26 | PERFECT.
f104r.27 | P08 | S08 | 3 | 27-29 | PERFECT.
f104r.30 | P09 | S09 | 4 | 30-33 | PERFECT.
f104r.34 | P10 | S10 | 2 | 34-35 | PERFECT.
f104r.36 | P11 | S11 | 3 | 36-38 | PERFECT.
f104r.39 | P12 | S12 | 4 | 39-42 | PERFECT.
f104r.43 | P13 | S13 | 3 | 43-45 | PERFECT.
PAGE | STR | SHL | PUF | XPF | XWL | PGH | TXL | PPG | PLN | IPG | ILN
f104r | 13 | 13 | 13 | 0 | 0 | 13 | 45 | 13 | 45 | 0 | 0
The obvious parag breaks of f104v, determined by short lines, are before lines 1 (@pchdaiin, with S01 at line 0.8), 6 (@solchd, S02 at 5.5), 8 (@tchodls, S03 at 7.7), 12 (@polchechy, S04 at 11.1), 15 (@S05 at 14.5), 19 (@pcheor, S06 aligned), 22 (@ytchedy, S07), 27 (@pchoror, S08 at 26.5), 29 (@kche, S09 aligned), 32 (@fchedy, S10 at 31.5), 35 (@psheodar, S11 at 34.5), 37 (@posairy, S12 aligned), and 41 (@tchedy, S13 at 40.2).
Line 45 is a "title" so line 44 is a tail. (Line 45 could be viewed as the final part of line 44. However, there is an extra-wide word gap and a drop of the baseline by ~1 o-height between @chey and @okeeey.)
Other than that, all the parag breaks on this page are clear, and all the parags turn out to be perfect.
PAGE ! SNN ! VPOS ! CORE ! PAINT ! CLR ! R ! T ! OBS
------+-----+------+------+-------+-----+---+---+---------------
f104v | S01 | 01.0 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | 1 | --
f104v | S02 | 05.5 | no | splot | yel | 8 | 1 | --
f104v | S03 | 08.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f104v | S04 | 11.0 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f104v | S05 | 14.5 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | 1 | --
f104v | S06 | 19.0 | no | splot | yel | 8 | 1 | --
f104v | S07 | 22.0 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | 1 | --
f104v | S08 | 26.8 | dot | splot | yel | 8 | 1 | --
f104v | S09 | 29.0 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | 1 | --
f104v | S10 | 31.5 | no | splot | yel | 8 | 1 | --
f104v | S11 | 35.0 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | 1 | --
f104v | S12 | 37.0 | no | splot | yel | 8 | 1 | --
f104v | S13 | 40.4 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | 1 | --
PLOC | PNN | SNN | NL | LRANGE | EVALUATION.
f104v.1 | P01 | S01 | 5 | 1-5 | PERFECT.
f104v.6 | P02 | S02 | 2 | 6-7 | PERFECT.
f104v.8 | P03 | S03 | 4 | 8-11 | PERFECT.
f104v.12 | P04 | S04 | 3 | 12-14 | PERFECT.
f104v.15 | P05 | S05 | 4 | 15-18 | PERFECT.
f104v.19 | P06 | S06 | 3 | 19-21 | PERFECT.
f104v.22 | P07 | S07 | 5 | 22-26 | PERFECT.
f104v.27 | P08 | S08 | 2 | 27-28 | PERFECT.
f104v.29 | P09 | S09 | 3 | 29-31 | PERFECT.
f104v.32 | P10 | S10 | 3 | 32-34 | PERFECT.
f104v.35 | P11 | S11 | 2 | 35-36 | PERFECT.
f104v.37 | P12 | S12 | 4 | 37-40 | PERFECT.
f104v.41 | P13 | S13 | 4 | 41-44 | PERFECT.
PAGE | STR | SHL | PUF | XPF | XWL | PGH | TXL | PPG | PLN | IPG | ILN
f104v | 13 | 13 | 8 | 0 | 0 | 13 | 44 | 13 | 44 | 0 | 0
The obvious parag breaks on f105r, after short lines, are before lines 1 (@paiir.dal, with star S01 in the top margin, above the fancy @p), 6 (@par.arody, with S02 at line 5.2), 11 (@pdaroshedy, S03 at 09.1), 14 (@kesoar, S04 at 13.7), 17 (@lkeedy, S05 at 16.8), 24 (@pcheor, S06 at 23.1), 26 (@pdar.sheey, S07 at 25.1), 28 (@pchsed, S08 at 27.1), 31 (@kodeey, S09 at 30.2), and 35 (@ypchedy, S10 at 33.5).
There is also a parag break before line 36, the last line of this page, which is generally assumed to be a "title".
Note that the stars are generally higher than the midline of the presumed matching head line, almost aligned with the tail of the previous parag. Star S10 is a ful 1.5 line higher than its head line (35). But all the stars have tails that extend down for several lines, and some of those tails are fat. The tail of S01 is even connected to the initial ornate puff of line 1. This possibly means that the "bullet" of each parag is a star together with its tail.
Something peculiar apparently happened in the writing of lines 10-13 of page f105r. Line 10 is right-justified and thus has sometimes been considered a title. However it avoids the gallows from the next line, indicating that it was written after it.
The baseline of line 11 starts to drop sharply just after the (half-?) word @pchos, beginning with the (half-?) word @aiin that lies just below the first word of line 10.
We conjectured that when the Scribe was writing line 11, sometime after the @pdar but no later than the @pchos, he realized that he had skipped those words. Thus he then lowered the baseline at that point in order to ensure that there would be enough space above it for those skipped words. And then, after finishing line 11, added those words in that space.
Given this assumption, we decided against leaving line 10 as a parag of its own or as the head of the next parag. Both options would be bad for statistical studies that look at parag lengths or at the words that occur at parag starts. We arbitrarily decided to remove the words @'sair,y.ore.daiin,dy.ytam' from line 10 of the transcription file, and insert them into line 11, just before the words @'oiiin,al'.
We left a single '?' on line 10 for the sake of programs that may choke on empty transcription lines. This line was explicitly excluded from the parag break evaluation, as if it was a title.
This hack still left the line blocks 6-9 and 11-13 as perfect parags. However, another peculiar detail is that line 13 ends with @ot, a very unusual word. And then there is a noticeable change in the pen/ink/font size between lines 13 and 14. It is possible that the Scribe that wrote up to line 13 stopped abrutly, in the middle of a word; and was replaced by another scribe -- who resumed with line 14, without completing line 13.
For these reasons, even though the fixed lines 11-13 are technically a perfect parag, it is advisable to exclude them from sensitive analyses.
Considering only the obvious breaks, lines 17-23 would be a single 7-line parag, with starlet S05. That would make it the longest parag of the SPS. While that alone would not make it uspicious, it also fails to be perfect because it has puff words below the head line: @paiir and olfaiin, both on line 20, and @ypair, @oepaiin, and @opail on line 22. It also has @opchey and @chefchedy on the short tail line (23).
Thus it seems likely that lines 17-23 are actually two or more parags, all but the first without starlets. We decided to break before lines 20 and 22. That created the parags 17-19 (3 lines), 20-21 (2 lines) and 22-23 (2 lines), none of them perfect. But these lines too should be excluded from parag-sensitive analyses.
PAGE ! SNN ! VPOS ! CORE ! PAINT ! CLR ! R ! T ! OBS
------+-----+------+------+-------+-----+---+---+---------------
f105r | S01 | 00.0 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | 1 | above_1st_word
f105r | S02 | 05.3 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 2 | --
f105r | S03 | 09.1 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f105r | S04 | 13.0 | -- | grub | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f105r | S05 | 15.7 | no | splot | yel | 8 | 2 | --
f105r | S06 | 22.1 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 2 | --
f105r | S07 | 24.1 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 2 | --
f105r | S08 | 26.1 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 2 | --
f105r | S09 | 29.1 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f105r | S10 | 32.7 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 2 | --
PLOC | PNN | SNN | NL | LRANGE | EVALUATION.
f105r.1 | P01 | S01 | 5 | 1-5 | PERFECT.
f105r.6 | P02 | S02 | 4 | 6-9 | PERFECT.
f105r.11 | P03 | S03 | 3 | 11-13 | PERFECT.
f105r.14 | P04 | S04 | 3 | 14-16 | PERFECT.
f105r.17 | P05 | S05 | 3 | 17-19 | not perfect: long tail, normal next linegap.
f105r.20 | P06 | NoS | 2 | 20-21 | not perfect: no starlet, long prev, normal prev linegap, long tail, normal next linegap.
f105r.22 | P07 | NoS | 2 | 22-23 | not perfect: no starlet, long prev, normal prev linegap, body puffs.
f105r.24 | P08 | S06 | 2 | 24-25 | PERFECT.
f105r.26 | P09 | S07 | 2 | 26-27 | PERFECT.
f105r.28 | P10 | S08 | 3 | 28-30 | not perfect: body puffs.
f105r.31 | P11 | S09 | 4 | 31-34 | not perfect: body puffs.
f105r.35 | P12 | S10 | 2 | 35-36 | PERFECT.
PAGE | STR | SHL | PUF | XPF | XWL | PGH | TXL | PPG | PLN | IPG | ILN
f105r | 10 | 10 | 14 | 3 | 0 | 12 | 35 | 7 | 21 | 5 | 14
The obvious parag breaks on page f105v, after page break or short lines, are before line 1 (@polary, with star S01 at line 0.8), 5 (@pchedal, with S02 at line 3.5, or 1.5 lines away), 8 (@podal, S03 at 7.2), 14 (@pchedaiin, S04 at 12.8), 18 (@pchor, S05 at 17.1), 20 (@porair, with S06 at 19.1), 23 (@tcholtaiin, S07 at 22.6), 25 (@tchdaldy, S08 aligned), 29 (@tdol, S09 at 28.2), and 32 (@poar, S10 at 9.6).
These breaks define 10 parags that would be perfect, except that many have puffs in the body lines. These spurious puffs are in lines 2, 3, 6, 11, 13, 15, 16, 21, 24 (2), and 27.
Thus only 18-19, 29-31, and 32-37 are perfect.
Considering only the obvious parag breaks on page f105v, lines 32-38 are a 7-line parag, which turns out to be the longest parag of the SPS. One should consider the possibility that it is two or more parags, all but the first without starlets.
There is a wide linegap between lines 37 and 38. Some may take that as a sign that it is a title. However, titles are usually right-justified or centered. Line 38 is unlikely to be a new parag because line 37 is long, the parag would be too short, there is no star nearby, and it has no puffs. We chose to disregard that linegap because it may have been an unconscious reaction by the Scribe when he reached the end of the page. On line 24, there is a baseline drop between @ckheol and @lkol, 2.5 words before the end of the line. However, it does not seem to be significant. Most likely, the Scribe just wanted to leave more space for the @k of @lkol.
Other than this wide linegap, there are no signs that 32-38 could be more than one parag, and no subtantial hints of where the additional breaks could be inserted. Thus we left it as a single parag. This decision turned out to be right in light of external evidence.
PAGE ! SNN ! VPOS ! CORE ! PAINT ! CLR ! R ! T ! OBS
------+-----+------+------+-------+-----+---+---+---------------
f105v | S01 | 01.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 2 | --
f105v | S02 | 03.5 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 2 | --
f105v | S03 | 07.5 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 2 | --
f105v | S04 | 12.7 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 2 | --
f105v | S05 | 17.1 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f105v | S06 | 19.1 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f105v | S07 | 23.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f105v | S08 | 25.0 | no | splot | yel | 8 | 1 | --
f105v | S09 | 28.3 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f105v | S10 | 32.0 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 2 | --
PLOC | PNN | SNN | NL | LRANGE | EVALUATION.
f105v.1 | P01 | S01 | 4 | 1-4 | not perfect: body puffs.
f105v.5 | P02 | S02 | 3 | 5-7 | not perfect: body puffs.
f105v.8 | P03 | S03 | 6 | 8-13 | not perfect: body puffs.
f105v.14 | P04 | S04 | 4 | 14-17 | not perfect: body puffs.
f105v.18 | P05 | S05 | 2 | 18-19 | PERFECT.
f105v.20 | P06 | S06 | 3 | 20-22 | not perfect: body puffs.
f105v.23 | P07 | S07 | 2 | 23-24 | not perfect: body puffs.
f105v.25 | P08 | S08 | 4 | 25-28 | not perfect: body puffs.
f105v.29 | P09 | S09 | 3 | 29-31 | PERFECT.
f105v.32 | P10 | S10 | 7 | 32-38 | PERFECT.
PAGE | STR | SHL | PUF | XPF | XWL | PGH | TXL | PPG | PLN | IPG | ILN
f105v | 10 | 10 | 20 | 10 | 0 | 10 | 38 | 3 | 12 | 7 | 26
On page f106r, the short lines determine obvious parag heads at lines 1 (@pshdar, with star S01 at line 1.1), 4 (@pcheodair, with S02 at 4.2), 8 (@porarchy, aligned with S03), 10 (@pshoair, aligned with S04), 13 (@pcheol, with S05 at 12.8), 15 (@padaroar, aligned with S06), 18 (@kshed, withS07 at 17.5), 22 (@tshodair, with S08 at 21.3), 24 (@podshedy, with S09 at 23.7), 27 (@tcheoky, with S10 at 26.7), 32 (@poral, with S11 at 31.6), 34 (@tchear, with S12 at 34.5), 36 (@psheodalo, with S13 at 36.3), 38 (@pshodaiin, with S14 at 37.7), and 42 (@pcheodar, aligned with S15).
There are no significant indications of other parag breaks. The last parag 42-47 has 6 lines, making it one of the longest in the SPS; but lines 41-46 are straight, parallel, and evenly spaced, and end at the right rail. Line 47 is a bit tilted, but it does not seem likely that it would be a parag all by itself.
Therefore, on f106r we took only the the obvious breaks, which define 15 paragd, all perfect.
Above star S03, which perfecly aligned with line 8, there is a tiny "baby" star that is aligned with line 7 (@olched). The two stars touch by the tips of the rays at 12:15 and 06:30, respectively. That tiny star is is not filled and is only ~3 mm across (half the size of the "parent"), but has 7 rays, a dot core in brown ink, and also red dot (not splot!) inside the body -- but off to one side, avoiding the dot core. It may also have a yel splot under the red dot.
If we accepted that baby star as a starlet for line 7, the latter would be a one-line parag, and lines 4-6 would be a parag with long tail line. Therefore we chose to ignore that baby star, and not assign it an S-number.
PAGE ! SNN ! VPOS ! CORE ! PAINT ! CLR ! R ! T ! OBS
------+-----+------+------+-------+-----+---+---+---------------
f106r | S01 | 01.5 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f106r | S02 | 04.5 | no | splot | yel | 8 | 1 | --
f106r | S03 | 08.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | w_tiny_star
f106r | S04 | 10.0 | no | splot | yel | 8 | 2 | --
f106r | S05 | 13.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f106r | S06 | 15.0 | ?? | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f106r | S07 | 17.7 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f106r | S08 | 21.3 | no | splot | yel | 8 | 1 | --
f106r | S09 | 24.0 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | 1 | --
f106r | S10 | 27.0 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f106r | S11 | 32.0 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | 1 | --
f106r | S12 | 34.6 | no | splot | yel | 8 | 1 | --
f106r | S13 | 36.5 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | 1 | --
f106r | S14 | 38.0 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f106r | S15 | 42.0 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | 1 | --
PLOC | PNN | SNN | NL | LRANGE | EVALUATION.
f106r.1 | P01 | S01 | 3 | 1-3 | PERFECT.
f106r.4 | P02 | S02 | 4 | 4-7 | PERFECT.
f106r.8 | P03 | S03 | 2 | 8-9 | PERFECT.
f106r.10 | P04 | S04 | 3 | 10-12 | PERFECT.
f106r.13 | P05 | S05 | 2 | 13-14 | PERFECT.
f106r.15 | P06 | S06 | 3 | 15-17 | PERFECT.
f106r.18 | P07 | S07 | 4 | 18-21 | PERFECT.
f106r.22 | P08 | S08 | 2 | 22-23 | PERFECT.
f106r.24 | P09 | S09 | 3 | 24-26 | PERFECT.
f106r.27 | P10 | S10 | 5 | 27-31 | PERFECT.
f106r.32 | P11 | S11 | 2 | 32-33 | PERFECT.
f106r.34 | P12 | S12 | 2 | 34-35 | PERFECT.
f106r.36 | P13 | S13 | 2 | 36-37 | PERFECT.
f106r.38 | P14 | S14 | 4 | 38-41 | PERFECT.
f106r.42 | P15 | S15 | 6 | 42-47 | PERFECT.
PAGE | STR | SHL | PUF | XPF | XWL | PGH | TXL | PPG | PLN | IPG | ILN
f106r | 15 | 15 | 15 | 0 | 0 | 15 | 47 | 15 | 47 | 0 | 0
On page f106v, the obvious parag breaks (because of short lines) are before lines 1 (@psheda, aligned with star S01), 5 (@ycheoto, with star S02 at line 4.5), 9 (@tshodaiin, with S03 at 8.5), 11 (@tchdys, aligned with S04), 15 (@tcheoykar, with S05 at 14.2), 18 (@pshodalos, aligned with S06), 20 (@polchs, S07 at 19.8) 22 (@tshod, no star nearby), 26 (@tarair, S08 at 25.5), 28 (@psheody, S09 at 28.2), 32 (@tolos, S10 aligned), 34 (@pchosaiin, S11 aligned), 37 (@pyoaly, S12 at 37.2), 40 (@ko.sheody, S13 at 39.5), and 42 (@py.chal, S14 aligned).
That makes 16 obvious parags but onlty 15 stars. There is no clue as to why parag 22-25 has no star nearby.
Other than that, all the parags defined by those obvious breaks turn out o be perfect. There is no indication that any of them could be two or more parags run together.
PAGE ! SNN ! VPOS ! CORE ! PAINT ! CLR ! R ! T ! OBS
------+-----+------+------+-------+-----+---+---+---------------
f106v | S01 | 01.0 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f106v | S02 | 04.5 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | 1 | --
f106v | S03 | 09.0 | no | splot | yel | 8 | 1 | --
f106v | S04 | 11.0 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | 1 | --
f106v | S05 | 14.2 | no | splot | yel | 8 | 1 | --
f106v | S06 | 18.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f106v | S07 | 20.0 | dot | splot | yel | 9 | 1 | --
f106v | S08 | 26.0 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | 1 | --
f106v | S09 | 28.2 | dot | splot | yel | 8 | 1 | faint_core
f106v | S10 | 32.0 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | 1 | --
f106v | S11 | 34.2 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f106v | S12 | 37.0 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | 1 | --
f106v | S13 | 40.0 | no | splot | yel | 8 | 1 | --
f106v | S14 | 42.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | grubbish
PLOC | PNN | SNN | NL | LRANGE | EVALUATION.
f106v.1 | P01 | S01 | 4 | 1-4 | PERFECT.
f106v.5 | P02 | S02 | 4 | 5-8 | PERFECT.
f106v.9 | P03 | S03 | 2 | 9-10 | PERFECT.
f106v.11 | P04 | S04 | 4 | 11-14 | PERFECT.
f106v.15 | P05 | S05 | 3 | 15-17 | PERFECT.
f106v.18 | P06 | S06 | 2 | 18-19 | PERFECT.
f106v.20 | P07 | S07 | 2 | 20-21 | PERFECT.
f106v.22 | P08 | NoS | 4 | 22-25 | not perfect: no starlet.
f106v.26 | P09 | S08 | 2 | 26-27 | PERFECT.
f106v.28 | P10 | S09 | 4 | 28-31 | PERFECT.
f106v.32 | P11 | S10 | 2 | 32-33 | PERFECT.
f106v.34 | P12 | S11 | 3 | 34-36 | PERFECT.
f106v.37 | P13 | S12 | 3 | 37-39 | PERFECT.
f106v.40 | P14 | S13 | 2 | 40-41 | PERFECT.
f106v.42 | P15 | S14 | 6 | 42-47 | PERFECT.
PAGE | STR | SHL | PUF | XPF | XWL | PGH | TXL | PPG | PLN | IPG | ILN
f106v | 14 | 15 | 15 | 0 | 0 | 15 | 47 | 14 | 43 | 1 | 4
Star S11 of this page has three dots at its left, in the dark-gray Retracer ink. We just ignored them.
On line 21, rhere is a baseline step down by ~1 o-height after @'taror', necessary because line 20 was sloping down.
On line 22 there is a baseline step down by ~1.5 o-height before the last word, @'lldy'. There seems to be no reason for that adjustment. It is possible that this word is not part of line 22 but an independent marginal note or tag. Since there is no other evidence of that, we kept that word in line 22.
Line 15 is a long line, but the next line is aligned with a star and the baselines diverge in the middle part. For these reasons we assumed a parag break between lines 15 and 16.
Line 33 is long, but line 34 is aligned with a star, has puffs (including an initial puff in @fairar) and the linegap between the two seems to be a tiny bit wider than average. So we assumed a parag break there, but did not mark the linegap as wide.
With these decisions, all parags turned out perfect, except for 30-33 and 34-37.
PAGE ! SNN ! VPOS ! CORE ! PAINT ! CLR ! R ! T ! OBS
------+-----+------+------+-------+-----+---+---+---------------
f107r | S01 | 01.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f107r | S02 | 03.5 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f107r | S03 | 08.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f107r | S04 | 13.0 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f107r | S05 | 16.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | short_tail
f107r | S06 | 18.2 | no | splot | yel | 8 | 1 | --
f107r | S07 | 20.5 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f107r | S08 | 23.7 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f107r | S09 | 27.5 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f107r | S10 | 30.0 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f107r | S11 | 34.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | three_dots
f107r | S12 | 38.2 | dot | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f107r | S13 | 42.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f107r | S14 | 45.0 | no | splot | yel | 8 | 2 | smeared_splot
f107r | S15 | 48.0 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | 1 | short_tail
PLOC | PNN | SNN | NL | LRANGE | EVALUATION.
f107r.1 | P01 | S01 | 3 | 1-3 | PERFECT.
f107r.4 | P02 | S02 | 4 | 4-7 | PERFECT.
f107r.8 | P03 | S03 | 5 | 8-12 | PERFECT.
f107r.13 | P04 | S04 | 3 | 13-15 | PERFECT.
f107r.16 | P05 | S05 | 2 | 16-17 | PERFECT.
f107r.18 | P06 | S06 | 3 | 18-20 | PERFECT.
f107r.21 | P07 | S07 | 3 | 21-23 | PERFECT.
f107r.24 | P08 | S08 | 3 | 24-26 | PERFECT.
f107r.27 | P09 | S09 | 3 | 27-29 | PERFECT.
f107r.30 | P10 | S10 | 4 | 30-33 | not perfect: long tail, normal next linegap.
f107r.34 | P11 | S11 | 4 | 34-37 | not perfect: long prev, normal prev linegap.
f107r.38 | P12 | S12 | 4 | 38-41 | PERFECT.
f107r.42 | P13 | S13 | 3 | 42-44 | PERFECT.
f107r.45 | P14 | S14 | 3 | 45-47 | PERFECT.
f107r.48 | P15 | S15 | 4 | 48-51 | not perfect: body puffs.
PAGE | STR | SHL | PUF | XPF | XWL | PGH | TXL | PPG | PLN | IPG | ILN
f107r | 15 | 13 | 13 | 1 | 0 | 15 | 51 | 12 | 39 | 3 | 12
Page f107v is the only one whose first line has no puffs. However, the last line of f107r is short, so the last parag of f107r cannot continue on page f107v, not even as an imperfect parag.
Star S01 has three reverse-comma marks on each side, aligned with two rays at 02:00 and 08:00. They seem to be in normal ink. We just ignored them.
The obvious parag breaks, because of short lines, are before lines 1 (@kaisar, with star S01 at line 0.8), 5 (@tol.sheockhedy, aligned with S02), 8 (@polcheolkain, S03), 11 (@tsehdy, S04), 16 (@parair, S05), 20 (@palar, S06 at 20.3), 23 (@palchor, S07 at 23.1), 25 (@kaolkar, S08 at 25.3), 29 (@tolkeeedy, S09 at 28.5), 32 (@okain, S10 at 31.8), 35 (@polchedy, S11 at 35.2), 37 (@poraiin, S12 at 36.7), 41 (@polkar, S13 at 40.5), 43 (@pol.keeeo, S14 at 42.5), and 45 (@porain, S15 at 45.5).
All parags turn out to be perfect, except lines 5-7, where line 6 starts with a puff initial, @paiin. It may be an "overflow" from the head line.
PAGE ! SNN ! VPOS ! CORE ! PAINT ! CLR ! R ! T ! OBS
------+-----+------+------+-------+-----+---+---+---------------
f107v | S01 | 01.0 | -- | splot | RED | 6 | 1 | triple_quotes.
f107v | S02 | 05.0 | dot | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f107v | S03 | 08.0 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | 1 | --
f107v | S04 | 11.0 | dot | splot | yel | 8 | 1 | short_tail
f107v | S05 | 16.0 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | 1 | --
f107v | S06 | 20.2 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f107v | S07 | 23.2 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f107v | S08 | 25.2 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f107v | S09 | 29.0 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | 1 | --
f107v | S10 | 32.0 | dot | splot | yel | 9 | 1 | --
f107v | S11 | 35.0 | -- | grub | RED | 8 | 1 | --
f107v | S12 | 37.0 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f107v | S13 | 40.8 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f107v | S14 | 42.5 | dot | splot | yel | 8 | 1 | --
f107v | S15 | 45.7 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | 1 | short_tail
PLOC | PNN | SNN | NL | LRANGE | EVALUATION.
f107v.1 | P01 | S01 | 4 | 1-4 | PERFECT.
f107v.5 | P02 | S02 | 3 | 5-7 | not perfect: body puffs.
f107v.8 | P03 | S03 | 3 | 8-10 | PERFECT.
f107v.11 | P04 | S04 | 5 | 11-15 | PERFECT.
f107v.16 | P05 | S05 | 4 | 16-19 | PERFECT.
f107v.20 | P06 | S06 | 3 | 20-22 | PERFECT.
f107v.23 | P07 | S07 | 2 | 23-24 | PERFECT.
f107v.25 | P08 | S08 | 4 | 25-28 | PERFECT.
f107v.29 | P09 | S09 | 3 | 29-31 | PERFECT.
f107v.32 | P10 | S10 | 3 | 32-34 | PERFECT.
f107v.35 | P11 | S11 | 2 | 35-36 | PERFECT.
f107v.37 | P12 | S12 | 4 | 37-40 | PERFECT.
f107v.41 | P13 | S13 | 2 | 41-42 | PERFECT.
f107v.43 | P14 | S14 | 2 | 43-44 | PERFECT.
f107v.45 | P15 | S15 | 5 | 45-49 | PERFECT.
PAGE | STR | SHL | PUF | XPF | XWL | PGH | TXL | PPG | PLN | IPG | ILN
f107v | 15 | 15 | 13 | 1 | 0 | 15 | 49 | 14 | 46 | 1 | 3
Obvious parag breaks on f108r, following short lines, are before lines 1 (@teodeeor, aligned with star S01), 5 (@tcholkedy, with S02 at 4.5), 8 (@pochedy, S03 at 7.5), 14 (@polchal, S05 at 13.8), 17 (@fcheokair, S06 at 16.7), 21 (@qolshy, S07 aligned), 24 (@folaiin, S08 at 23.8), 29 (@polchedy, S09 at 28.5), 31 (@keol, S10 at 30.7), 35 (@pychory, S11 at 34.7), 37 (@tchedy, S12 at 36.5), 39 (@porol, S13 at 38.5, and 45 (@dain, S15 at 44.5).
These breaks define parags 1-4, 5-7), 14-16, 17-20, 21-23, 24-18, 29-30, 31-34, 35-36, and 37-38. We are left with unsplit blocks 8-13 (with S03 and unassigned star S04), 39-44 (S13 and unassigned S14), and 45-50 (S15 and unassigned S16).
There are obvious breaks on f108r before line 8 (@pochedy) and after line 13. Star S03 is naturally assigned to line 8, that begins with a puff. Star S05 is naturally assigned to line 14. That leaves star S04 unassigned.
Line 10 (@taiin) follows a slightly shorter line 9 (@cthey) and there linegap between them is a bit irregular.
Line 11 (@teodeey) is aligned with star S04 and begins with an extra-wide @t. However line 10 is long and the linegap between 10 and 11 is normal.
Line 12 (@tshey) is a bit longer than 11, but 11 is the same length as 10. The linegap between 11 and 12 is normal.
Thus we decided to break the 8-13 block before 1ine 10 (@taiin) and assign star S04 to it, even though it is 0.7 lines lower.
There is a baseline discontinuity on line 10 after the word @qoteey, so perhaps the parag break is actually there.
It is also possible that S04 was not meant to exist, in which case lines 8-13 would be a perfect six-line parag. Maybe the Scribe skipped another star further down the page, counted the stars, realized that one was missing, and guessed that it was in the wider gap of lines 8-13. Or maybe S04 was added just because that bigger gap seemed wrong. Anyway, if we adopted this hypothesis, we would have to decide whether a star was missing elsewhere, and guess where it should have been. Any choice here would not be satisfactory.
Another alternative hypothesis is that Stars S02, S03, and S04 are shifted by ~2.5 lineseps downwards from their correct positions. Maybe the scribe did not notice a parag break on line 02 (see puff) and instead thought that line 11 was a parag head. If we assumed this hypothesis, then line 1 would be a parag by itself, lines 2-4, 5-7, 8-13 would be parags with 3, 3, and 6 lines, respectively. The last two would be perfect, but only if we ignore the large distance between the vertical position of those three stars and the midlines of the lines. Not plausible either.
There are obvious breaks on f108r before line 39 (@parol) and after line 44. Star S13 is naturally assigned to line 39, that begins with a puff. Star S15 is naturally assigned to line 45. That leaves star S14 unassigned.
Line 41 (@sheedain) follows a wide linegap and a line that ends with @m. It is 0.7 above the star S14.
Line 42 (@okeey) is closest to S14, but line 41 is long and the linegap 41-42is normal.
Neither 41 nor 42 have puffs or other indicators of parag head. Thus we chose to break the block before line 41 and assign S14 to this line. creating two parags with 2 and 4 lines, respectively.
There is an obvious break on f108r before line 45 (@dain.shecky) Star S15 is naturally assigned to line 45. That leaves star S16 unassigned.
Line 48 (@pcheedy) begins with a puff, is aligned with S16 and ends in @m. The only flaw with this choice is that line 47 is only slightly short, and the linegap 47-48 is normal. Still, that seems to be the best option.
PAGE ! SNN ! VPOS ! CORE ! PAINT ! CLR ! R ! T ! OBS
------+-----+------+------+-------+-----+---+---+---------------
f108r | S01 | 01.2 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | stain
f108r | S02 | 04.7 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f108r | S03 | 07.7 | -- | frub | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f108r | S04 | 10.8 | no | frub | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f108r | S05 | 14.0 | no | grub | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f108r | S06 | 17.0 | dot | frub | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f108r | S07 | 21.0 | -- | frub | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f108r | S08 | 24.0 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | grubbish
f108r | S09 | 29.0 | no | no | -- | 7 | 1 | --
f108r | S10 | 31.0 | -- | frub | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f108r | S11 | 35.0 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f108r | S12 | 37.0 | -- | fill | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f108r | S13 | 39.0 | no | no | -- | 7 | 1 | --
f108r | S14 | 41.7 | dot | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f108r | S15 | 44.5 | dot | no | -- | 7 | 1 | --
f108r | S16 | 48.0 | -- | fill | RED | 7 | 1 | --
PLOC | PNN | SNN | NL | LRANGE | EVALUATION.
f108r.1 | P01 | S01 | 4 | 1-4 | not perfect: body puffs.
f108r.5 | P02 | S02 | 3 | 5-7 | PERFECT.
f108r.8 | P03 | S03 | 2 | 8-9 | PERFECT.
f108r.10 | P04 | S04 | 4 | 10-13 | PERFECT.
f108r.14 | P05 | S05 | 3 | 14-16 | PERFECT.
f108r.17 | P06 | S06 | 4 | 17-20 | PERFECT.
f108r.21 | P07 | S07 | 3 | 21-23 | PERFECT.
f108r.24 | P08 | S08 | 5 | 24-28 | not perfect: body puffs.
f108r.29 | P09 | S09 | 2 | 29-30 | PERFECT.
f108r.31 | P10 | S10 | 4 | 31-34 | PERFECT.
f108r.35 | P11 | S11 | 2 | 35-36 | PERFECT.
f108r.37 | P12 | S12 | 2 | 37-38 | PERFECT.
f108r.39 | P13 | S13 | 2 | 39-40 | PERFECT.
f108r.41 | P14 | S14 | 4 | 41-44 | PERFECT.
f108r.45 | P15 | S15 | 3 | 45-47 | PERFECT.
f108r.48 | P16 | S16 | 3 | 48-50 | PERFECT.
PAGE | STR | SHL | PUF | XPF | XWL | PGH | TXL | PPG | PLN | IPG | ILN
f108r | 16 | 16 | 13 | 2 | 0 | 16 | 50 | 14 | 41 | 2 | 9
The parag breaks on f108v are rather problematic. There are 16 stars and 52 lines (not counting line 53, a title), and no matter how we split the latter into 16 parags, many will be imperfect because they end in long lines. In fact, most of the lines 1-19 are visibly compressed near the narrow right margin, way too many of them ending with @m (which is suspected of being an abbreviation sign). Then, starting with line 30, there are no visible parag breaks at all; not even any puffs, except for the first word of line 30 (@polshedaiin). Lines 51 and 52 even overshoot the right rail and reach almost to be binding fold.
It is almost if the Scribe had been admonished for using too much vellum, and over-reacted by squeezing and abbreviating, then by eliminating parag breaks altogether.
The only obvious parag breaks, after short tails, are before lines 5 (@polaiin), 15 (@pcheor), 20 (@polkeedal), and 30 (@polshedaiin), which are aligned with stars S02, S05, S06, and S09.
That defines parags 1-4 (@pchedal, starlet S01, perfect) and 15-19 (@pcheor, starlet S05). It leaves unsplit blocks 5-14 (stars S02-S04), 20-29 (S06-S08), and 30-52 (S09-S16).
There are obvious breaks on f108v before line 5 (@polaiin) and after line 14. Stars S02 and S05 are obviously assigned to lines 5 and 15, leaving S03 and S04 unassigned.
Line 7 (@pchedaiin) starts with a puff word and is aligned with S03. It is not an obvious break because line 6 is long and the linegap 6-7 is only sly wider at left. But there are no other plausible candidates so we broke before line 7 and assigned S03 to it, defnining lines 5-6 as a parag.
That leaves imperfect block 7-14 (with unassigned star S04). The situation can be summarized as:
0 0 0 1 1 1 1 1
7 8 9 0 1 2 3 4
-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-
S . . . .S. . .
0 . . . .0. . .
3 . . . .4. . .
. . . . . « . .
. . . . n w . .
p . . . . . . .
m . m m . m . .
where 'S' is a star, aligned with the line or between two lines; 'p' means that the line contains puffs, 'w' and 'W' mean that the previous linegap is wider than normal, '«' means that the previous line is somewhat short, 'm' that the previous line ends with @m or @g.
On f108v, line 11 (@sain) is 0.5 above star S04. It is 3 glyphs shorter than 10, that ends with @am, but resets the right rail. The linegap 10-11 is narrower than normal.
Line 12 (@tshedky) is 0.5 below the star. The prev line is 0.5 glyphs shorter than line 12. The linegap 11-12 is a bit wider in the middle, but maybe because 11 is exceptional.
We decided to break before line 11 and assign S04 to it. That defines parags 7-10 and 11-14.
There is a baseline discontinuity on line 11 after @keedain. Possibly the parag break is there.
On f108v there are obvious breaks before line 20 (@polkeedal) and after line 29. The obvious assignments are S06 to line 20 and S09 to 30 (@polshedaiin). That leaves an unsplit block 20-29 with unassigned stars S07,S08. The situation is:
2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-
S . . .S. . S . . .
0 . . .0. . 0 . . .
6 . . .7. . 8 . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
p . . . . . . . p .
. . . . m . . m . m
We assumed that there would be two parag breaks in this range, mathching the two unassigned stars.
Star S08 is approximately aligned with line 26 (@sair), but there is nothing else suggesting that 26 could be a headline.
On the other hand, line 28 (@paror) begins with puff, the only puff word in lines 21-29, and line 27 ends with @am.
So we determined a parag break before line 28, and assigned S08 to it.
Then we must assign S07 to one of the lines 21-27. There are no puffs or wide linegaps in that area. It is almost aligned with line 23 (@qokeeor). For the lack of any other clues, we assigned S07 to line 23 and split just before it.
These choices split the block into parags 20-22 (@polkeedal, S06), 23-27 (@qokeeor, S07), and 28-29 (@paror, S08).
On f108v there is an obvious break before line 30 (@polshedaiin), with obvious starlet S09. Line 53 is assumed to be a title. That leaves lines 30-52 as an unsplit block unassigned stars S10-S16. The situation is:
3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 5 5 5
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 0 1 2
-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-
S . . . .S. .S. . .S. . .S. . .S. .S. . .S. .
0 . . . .1. .1. . .1. . .1. . .1. .1. . .1. .
9 . . . .0. .1. . .2. . .3. . .4. .5. . .6. .
. . . w . . . . . . w w . . . w . . . . w . .
. . . « . . . . « . « . . « . . . . . « . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. m m . . m . m . . m . . . . . . . m . . . .
Apparently the Author or someone else faced this problem too, because on f108v there are thin lines that connect those stars to specific text lines: S10:33, S11:36, S12:39, S13:42, S14:45, S15:48, S16:50.
The lines that follow lines that end in @m (or @g) are 32, 33, 36, 38, 39, 44, 45, 50.
The linegaps before lines 40, 41, 45 are slightly wider than the others, in the middle region, and that before line 50 is wider at about 1/3 of the line. These are the only noticeable ones.
So lets assign S14 to line 45 (@sheol), and S16 to line 50 (@dsheey). Each of these has three weak clues while the other candidates have at most two.
That defines parag 50-52 (@dsheey) with starlet S16.
We now have block 30-44 with unassigned stars S10-S13, and block 45-49 with unassigned star S15.
3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+- -+-+-+-+-
S . . . .S. .S. . .S. . .S. . S . .S. .
0 . . . .1. .1. . .1. . .1. . 1 . .1. .
9 . . . .0. .1. . .2. . .3. . 4 . .5. .
. . . w . . . . . . w w . . . . . . . .
. . . « . . . . « . « . . « . . . . . «
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. m m . . m . m . . m . . . . . . . m .
Star S15 lies between lines 47 and 48. Disagreeing with the anonymous Connector, I assigned S15 to line 47, creating parags with lines 45-46 (@sheol, S14) and 47-49 (@ycheey, S15).
The most plausible candidates for S12 are lines 38-40.
Line 38 (@dsheol) ends in @am.
Line 39 (@sain) is 0.8 above star S12 and the linegap 38-39 is narrower than normal because the baseline has a kink. It is the guess of the anonymous Connector.
Line 40 (@daiin) is 0.2 below star S12 and the linegap 39-40 is a bit wider below the kink of line 39.
Agreeing with the Connector, I assigned S12 to line 39.
However, there is a baseline step on line 39 after @lkedain, suggesting that the parag break is actually at that step.
The assignment of S12 split the block into lines 30-38 (with unassigned S10,S11) and lines 39-44 (with unassigned S13). The situation became:
3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 4 4 4 4 4
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 0 1 2 3 4
-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+- -+-+-+-+-+-
S . . . .S. .S. . S . . .S. .
0 . . . .1. .1. . 1 . . .1. .
9 . . . .0. .1. . 2 . . .3. .
. . . w . . . . . . w w . . .
. . . « . . . . « . « . . « .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. m m . . m . m . . m . . . .
On f108v, the linegap 42-43 is very slightly wider near the left rail. The star S13 is closer to line 43 (@shodain) than to 42 (@ycheain). Line 42 is shorter than 41 by half a glyph (although 43 has the same length). On the other hand, the Connector guessed 42.
We chose to disregard the Connector. We broke before 43 and assigned S13 to it. That defined two more parags, 39-42 (@saiin, S12) and 43-44 (@shodain, S13).
Star S11 is between 36 (second @daiin) and 37 (@sain), which are the most plausible candidates for it.
Line 36 is the Connector's guess for S11. Line 35 ends in @am.
Line 37 is a bit short and ends in @am. Prev line 36 is not short and does not end in @am.
I went with the Connector on this one, and broke before line 36, assigning S11 to it; even though I have a hunch that it is wrong.
Next we split 30-35 with unassigned star S10, which lies just a bit below line 34 (@tolshey).
Line 33 (@sain) is the Connector's suggestion. The linegap 32-33 is sly wider at the right end. Line 32 ends with @am. and is 1 glyph shorter than 31 and 33.
Line 34 (@tolshey ) begins with a wide @t. Linegap 33-34 is sly wider in the middle. But prev line 33 is longer by 1 glyph.
Line 35 is 1 glyph shorter than 34.
So we go with the Connector's hunch and assign S10 to line 33.
These choices split lines 30-38 into parags 30-32 (@polshedaiin, S09), 33-35 (@sain, S10), and 36-38 (second @daiin, S11).
PAGE ! SNN ! VPOS ! CORE ! PAINT ! CLR ! R ! T ! OBS
------+-----+------+------+-------+-----+---+---+---------------
f108v | S01 | 01.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f108v | S02 | 04.4 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f108v | S03 | 07.0 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | 1 | --
f108v | S04 | 12.0 | dot | splot | yel | 8 | 1 | --
f108v | S05 | 15.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f108v | S06 | 20.0 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f108v | S07 | 23.0 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | 1 | --
f108v | S08 | 26.0 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f108v | S09 | 29.5 | dot | splot | yel | 8 | 1 | --
f108v | S10 | 34.0 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | 1 | --
f108v | S11 | 37.0 | no | splot | yel | 8 | 1 | --
f108v | S12 | 39.5 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f108v | S13 | 42.5 | dot | splot | yel | 8 | 1 | --
f108v | S14 | 45.5 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f108v | S15 | 48.0 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f108v | S16 | 50.2 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
PLOC | PNN | SNN | NL | LRANGE | EVALUATION.
f108v.1 | P01 | S01 | 4 | 1-4 | PERFECT.
f108v.5 | P02 | S02 | 2 | 5-6 | not perfect: long tail, normal next linegap.
f108v.7 | P03 | S03 | 4 | 7-10 | not perfect: long prev, normal prev linegap, long tail, normal next linegap.
f108v.11 | P04 | S04 | 4 | 11-14 | not perfect: long prev, normal prev linegap.
f108v.15 | P05 | S05 | 5 | 15-19 | not perfect: body puffs.
f108v.20 | P06 | S06 | 3 | 20-22 | not perfect: long tail, normal next linegap.
f108v.23 | P07 | S07 | 5 | 23-27 | not perfect: long prev, normal prev linegap, long tail, normal next linegap.
f108v.28 | P08 | S08 | 2 | 28-29 | not perfect: long prev, normal prev linegap.
f108v.30 | P09 | S09 | 3 | 30-32 | not perfect: long tail, normal next linegap.
f108v.33 | P10 | S10 | 3 | 33-35 | not perfect: long prev, normal prev linegap, long tail, normal next linegap.
f108v.36 | P11 | S11 | 3 | 36-38 | not perfect: long prev, normal prev linegap, long tail, normal next linegap.
f108v.39 | P12 | S12 | 4 | 39-42 | not perfect: long prev, normal prev linegap, long tail, normal next linegap.
f108v.43 | P13 | S13 | 2 | 43-44 | not perfect: long prev, normal prev linegap, long tail, normal next linegap.
f108v.45 | P14 | S14 | 2 | 45-46 | not perfect: long prev, normal prev linegap, long tail, normal next linegap.
f108v.47 | P15 | S15 | 3 | 47-49 | not perfect: long prev, normal prev linegap, long tail, normal next linegap.
f108v.50 | P16 | S16 | 3 | 50-52 | not perfect: long prev, normal prev linegap.
PAGE | STR | SHL | PUF | XPF | XWL | PGH | TXL | PPG | PLN | IPG | ILN
f108v | 16 | 6 | 8 | 1 | 0 | 16 | 52 | 1 | 4 | 15 | 48
On f111r we have the same difficulty of f108v, namely many consecutive long lines with no obvious signs of parag beaks, and stars that do not seem to be aligned with parag heads.
The obvious breaks are before lines 6 (star S02, first word @dain), 36 (S13, @polal), 44 (S15, @pchedar), and 48 (S16, @poeokeey). Those assignments define parags 1-5 (S01) and 44-47 (S15). They leave blocks 6-35 (with unassigned stars S03-S12), 36-43 (unassigned S14), and 48-54 (unassigned S17).
In the big block 6-35 of f111r, there are slightly wider linegaps at right before lines 7 (@sshedy), 8 (@daiin), 9 (@ycheeodain), 16 (@dched), 17 (@otes), and 22 (@s,sheol). There are noticeably wider linegaps at right before lines 15 (@sheeodar) and 31 (@sheotchedy). There are slightly wider linegaps at left before 21 (@daiin) and 25 (@so,shear). There are slightly wider linegaps in the middle before lines 10 (@ykeedaiin), 24 (@sain), 28 (@qokeeol) and 32 (@dsheeoteey).
The only puffs in that block are on lines 14 and 15, but not in line-initial position.
Slightly shorter lines occur before line 13 (-2.0 glyphs), 23 (-2.0), 25 (-3.0), 31 (-1.0), 33 (-1.0), and 35 (-1.0). (Line 23 is three glyphs shorter but only because of intruding tail from 22.)
Lines ending in @m occur before lines 8, 10, 12, 13, 16, 18, 21, 29, and 36.
In summary, the situation is as follows:
0 0 0 0 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 3 3 3 3 3 3
6 7 8 9 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 0 1 2 3 4 5
-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-
S .S. .S. . . S . . .S. . .S. . . S . .S. . .S. . .S. .S. .
0 .0. .0. . . 0 . . .0. . .0. . . 0 . .0. . .1. . .1. .1. .
2 .3. .4. . . 5 . . .6. . .7. . . 8 . .9. . .0. . .1. .2. .
. w w w w . . . . W w w . . . w w . w w . w w . w W w . . .
. . . . . . . « . . . . . . . . . « . « . . . . . « . « . «
. . . . . . . . p p . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. m . m . m m . . m . m . . m . . . . . . . m . . . . . . m
We put a break before 31 (@sheotchedy), with starlet S11, because of the wide linegap, the slightly shorter line before it, and the star nearby.
We also put a break before line 25 (@soshear), with starlet S09, because of the slightly wider linegap and the slightly shorter prev line.
We put a parag break before 15 because of the wide linegap and the puff. Stars S05 and S06 are equally far away (1.5 linegaps). Lacking better criteria, we assigned S06, which will leave S05 for a better assignment later.
The situation became:
0 0 0 0 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 3 3 3 3 3 3
6 7 8 9 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 0 1 2 3 4 5
-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+- -+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+- -+-+-+-+-+- -+-+-+-+-
S . S .S. . . .S. S . . . .S. . . .S. S . . . S . S . . S .
0 . 0 .0. . . .0. 0 . . . .0. . . .0. 0 . . . 1 . 1 . . 1 .
2 . 3 .4. . . .5. 6 . . . .7. . . .8. 9 . . . 0 . 1 . . 2 .
. w w w w . . . . . w w . . . w w . w . . w w . w . w . . .
. . . . . . . « . . . . . . . . . « . «. . . . . . « . « . «
. . . . . . . . p p . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. m . m . m m . . m . m . . m . . . . . . . m . . . . . . m
We broke before line 33, assigning S12 to it, because of the nearby star and sly shorter prev line.
We broke before line 29, assigning S10 to it, for the nearby star and lack of other clues. It helps that the prev line ends in @m.
That defined parags 25-28, 29-30, 31-32, 33-35.
We broke before line 13, with starlet S05, because of the shorter prev line and prev final @m.
Then the best choice for the remaindes of the first block seems to be breaks before lines 8 (@daiin) and 10 (@ykeedaii), with starlets S03 (aligned) and S04 (0.5 down). That defines parags 6-7 and 8-9.
For the second block, a break at 22 seems to be most likely, and then S08 (1.2 lines away) seems to be the best starlet. That defines parag 22-24.
We are left with:
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 2
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 0 1
-+-+-+-+- -+-+-+-+-+-+-
S . . .S. S . . . .S. .
0 . . .0. 0 . . . .0. .
4 . . .5. 6 . . . .7. .
. . . . . . . . . . . w
. . . « . . . . . . . .
. . . . p p . . . . . .
. m m . . m . m . . m .
For the first block, a break at 13 with starlet S05 (0.2 below) now seems logical, thus defining parags 10-12 and 13-14.
For the second block, we could break at 19 or 20 because of the nearby star, at 18 because of the prev @m final, or 21 becaue of the prev @m final and slighlty wider linegap above. The last choice would leave parags with 6 and 1 lines. We chose to break at 19 with starlet S07, thus defining parags 15-18 (4 lines) and 19-21 (3 lines).
On f111r, there is no obvious break in lines 36-43,all the lines 36-42 are long. There are no puffs except on line 36, and no significant internal wide linegaps. The vpos of star S14 is 38.8 and line 38 is two glyphs shorter than 37 and 39.
So we put a parag break before line 39 (first @saiin), and assigned S14 to it.
That split the block into parags 36-38 (@polal, S13) and 39-43 (first @saiin, S14).
On f111r, there is no obvious break in lines 48-54, because all the lines 48-53 are long. But S17 is aligned with line 51 (@palkeeo), with begins with a puff. There are no other puffs in that block except at line 48. The baseline of 51 is not parallel to that of line 50, which has a kink after @chedy.
So we defined a parag break before line 51 and assigned S17 to it. That splits the block into parags 48-50 (@poeokeey, S16) and 51-54 (@palkeeo, S17).
PAGE ! SNN ! VPOS ! CORE ! PAINT ! CLR ! R ! T ! OBS
------+-----+------+------+-------+-----+---+---+---------------
f111r | S01 | 01.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f111r | S02 | 06.0 | no | splot | yel | 8 | 1 | brownish_yel
f111r | S03 | 08.0 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | 1 | --
f111r | S04 | 10.0 | dot | splot | yel | 8 | 1 | --
f111r | S05 | 13.2 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | 1 | --
f111r | S06 | 16.5 | dot | splot | yel | 8 | 1 | --
f111r | S07 | 19.5 | -- | splot | RED | 9 | 1 | bifurc_tail
f111r | S08 | 23.2 | no | splot | yel | 8 | 1 | lost_dot?
f111r | S09 | 25.7 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | 1 | --
f111r | S10 | 29.0 | no | splot | yel | 8 | 1 | --
f111r | S11 | 31.5 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | 1 | --
f111r | S12 | 34.0 | no | splot | yel | 8 | 1 | --
f111r | S13 | 36.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f111r | S14 | 39.0 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f111r | S15 | 43.7 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f111r | S16 | 47.5 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f111r | S17 | 51.0 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | 2 | bifurc_tail
PLOC | PNN | SNN | NL | LRANGE | EVALUATION.
f111r.1 | P01 | S01 | 5 | 1-5 | PERFECT.
f111r.6 | P02 | S02 | 2 | 6-7 | not perfect: long tail, normal next linegap.
f111r.8 | P03 | S03 | 2 | 8-9 | not perfect: long prev, normal prev linegap, long tail, normal next linegap.
f111r.10 | P04 | S04 | 3 | 10-12 | not perfect: long prev, normal prev linegap, long tail, normal next linegap.
f111r.13 | P05 | S05 | 2 | 13-14 | not perfect: long prev, normal prev linegap, body puffs.
f111r.15 | P06 | S06 | 4 | 15-18 | not perfect: long tail, normal next linegap.
f111r.19 | P07 | S07 | 3 | 19-21 | not perfect: long prev, normal prev linegap, internal wide linegap.
f111r.22 | P08 | S08 | 3 | 22-24 | PERFECT.
f111r.25 | P09 | S09 | 4 | 25-28 | not perfect: long tail, normal next linegap.
f111r.29 | P10 | S10 | 2 | 29-30 | not perfect: long prev, normal prev linegap.
f111r.31 | P11 | S11 | 2 | 31-32 | not perfect: internal wide linegap, long tail, normal next linegap.
f111r.33 | P12 | S12 | 3 | 33-35 | not perfect: long prev, normal prev linegap.
f111r.36 | P13 | S13 | 3 | 36-38 | PERFECT.
f111r.39 | P14 | S14 | 5 | 39-43 | PERFECT.
f111r.44 | P15 | S15 | 4 | 44-47 | PERFECT.
f111r.48 | P16 | S16 | 3 | 48-50 | not perfect: long tail, normal next linegap.
f111r.51 | P17 | S17 | 4 | 51-54 | not perfect: long prev, normal prev linegap.
PAGE | STR | SHL | PUF | XPF | XWL | PGH | TXL | PPG | PLN | IPG | ILN
f111r | 17 | 8 | 7 | 1 | 2 | 17 | 54 | 5 | 20 | 12 | 34
On f111v, again, lines 1-25 apparently consist of a bunch of paragraphs joined into a single big paragraph with several stars on the margin. But after that he returned to almost normal paragraph format.
We will try to insert parag breaks before certain lines, but they will almost certainly be wrong because the breaks should be inside the lines.
Obvious parag breaks (because of short prev lines) are at line 26 (@polarar, starlet S11), 29 (@polkiin, S12), 34 (@polar, S15), 37 (@palchey, S16), 39 (@dsheey, S17), 45 (@pollaiin, S18), and 48 (@psalar, S19). There is also a substantial wide linegap at right before line 20 (@shain, S09).
Those breaks define parags 26-28 (S11), 34-36 (S15), 37-38 (S16), 39-44 (S17), 45-47 (S18), and 48-51 (S19). We are left with three unsplit blocks: 1-19 (with unassigned stars S02-S08), 20-25 (unassigned S10), and 29-33 (unassigned S13, S14).
Within lines 1-19 of f111v, there puffs in lines 2, 7, 16.
Slightly wider linegaps in that range occur before lines 2 (whole line), 4 (mid-right), 7 (middle), 10 (middle), 12 (right), 13 (right), 16 (right), and 19 (right)
Slightly shorter lines in that range occur before lines 4 (-1.5 glyphs), 5 (-1.0), 10 (-1.5), 11 (-0.5), 13 (-0.5), 14 (-1.0), and 18 (-1.5).
Lines ending with @m occur before lines 4, 5, 7, 9, 10, 12, 15, and 18.
The situation is:
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-
S . . S .S. . S . .S. .S. . .S. . S .
0 . . 0 .0. . 0 . .0. .0. . .0. . 0 .
1 . . 2 .3. . 4 . .5. .6. . .7. . 8 .
. w . w . . w . . w . w w . . w . . W
. « . « « . . . . « « . . « . . . « .
p p . . . . p . . . . . . . . p . . .
. . . m m . m . m m . m . . m . . m .
A breaks at 16 (@qokain, with starlet S07) is now almost obvious.
We also take a break at 07 (@qokeechey) because of the puffs, and at 18 (@tair, with S08) because of the shorter line above and no better option. We assign the break at 7 with S04, rather than S03, even though S04 is aligned with line 8.
The situation then becomes:
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
-+-+-+-+-+- -+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+- -+-+-+-
S . . S .S. S . . .S. .S. . . S . S .
0 . . 0 .0. 0 . . .0. .0. . . 0 . 0 .
1 . . 2 .3. 4 . . .5. .6. . . 7 . 8 .
. w . w . . w . . w . w w . . w w . w
. « . « « . . . . « « . . « . . . «
p p . . . . p . . . . . . . . p . . .
. . . m m . m . m m . . . . m . m . .
We then split at line 2 (@sheekeey) with starlet S02, because of the puffs, wider linegap, and slightly shorter prev line. Star S02 is 2 lines away, but that could be because star S01 and its tail left no space for S02 at the proper place.
We still split at line 4, but with starlet S03. This star is 1.5 lines away, but after drawing S02 that was the closest that S03 could be to line 4.
Of the candidates for S05, line 10 follows a sly shorter line that ends with @m. Line So let's break before line 10 (@saiin) and assign S05 to it.
Then it is more logical to break before line 13 (@sheaiin) and assign it S06, because the linegap 12-13 is wider than 11-12.
For S08, which is aligned with line 18 (@tar), the best choice is not obvious. Line 17 has a wider linegap 16-17 and line 16 ends in @m. Line 18 has a sly wide linegap and line 17 is sly short. Line 19 has a sly wide linegap. So we break at line 18 and assign S08 to it.
That defines parags 1-1 (@pashey, S01), 2-3 (@sheekeey, S02), 4-6 (@daiin, S03), 7-9 (@qokeechedy, S04), 10-12 (@saiin, S05), 13-15 (S06), 16-17 (@qokain, S07), and 18-19 (@tar, S08).
On f111v, there are no puffs in line 20-25.
The only noticeable (but slightly) wider linegap in this rage is before lines 20 and 25 (on the right side).
Slightly shorter lines within this range occur before lines 20 (-1.0), 23 (-0.5) and 24 (-1.5).
Lines ending with @m occur before lines 22, 23, 25.
The situation is:
2 2 2 2 2 2
0 1 2 3 4 5
-+-+-+-+-+-
S . . .S. .
0 . . .1. .
9 . . .0. .
W . . . . w
« . . « . «
. . . . . .
. . m . m m
For S10 of f111v, the closest candidates are line 23 and 24. Line 23 (@qotaiin) has a shorter prev line and is itself longer than neighbors. Line 24 (@cheodain) has a noticeably wider linegap at right and a prev line ending in @m. But line 24 itself is short and ends in @m. It seems safer to break before line 24 with starlet S10.
That defines parags 20-23 (@shain, S09) and 24-25 (@cheodain, S10).
In lines 29-33 of f111v, there are puffs only in lines 29 and 31.
Slightly wider linegaps in this range occur before lines 31 (on the left side) and 33 (ditto).
The only line ending with @m occurs before line 32.
Slightly shorter lines in this range occur before lines 32 (-1.0 glyphs) and 33 (-1.0).
The situation is:
2 3 3 3 3
9 0 1 2 3
-+-+-+-+-
S .S.S. .
1 .1.1. .
2 .3.4. .
. . w . w
. . . « «
p . p . .
. . . m .
A break at 31 (@pochey) is now almost obvious. We pick S13 as ]its starlet, so that we can break at 32 (@tar) with S14.
That defines parags 29-30 (@polkiin, S12), 31-31 (@pochey, S13), and 32-33 (@tar, S14).
PAGE ! SNN ! VPOS ! CORE ! PAINT ! CLR ! R ! T ! OBS
------+-----+------+------+-------+-----+---+---+---------------
f111v | S01 | 01.0 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | 1 | --
f111v | S02 | 04.0 | no | splot | yel | 7 | - | --
f111v | S03 | 05.8 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f111v | S04 | 08.0 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f111v | S05 | 10.7 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | - | --
f111v | S06 | 13.0 | dot | splot | yel | 8 | - | --
f111v | S07 | 15.5 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | - | --
f111v | S08 | 18.0 | dot | splot | yel | 7 | - | --
f111v | S09 | 20.7 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f111v | S10 | 23.5 | dot | no | -- | 8 | - | retraced_dot?
f111v | S11 | 26.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | - | --
f111v | S12 | 28.5 | no | splot | yel | 7 | - | --
f111v | S13 | 30.3 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | - | --
f111v | S14 | 32.0 | dot | splot | yel | 7 | - | --
f111v | S15 | 33.5 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | 1 | --
f111v | S16 | 36.5 | dot | splot | yel | 8 | - | --
f111v | S17 | 39.5 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | - | --
f111v | S18 | 44.5 | no | splot | yel | 7 | - | ray_retraced?
f111v | S19 | 47.5 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | - | --
PLOC | PNN | SNN | NL | LRANGE | EVALUATION.
f111v.1 | P01 | S01 | 1 | 1-1 | PERFECT.
f111v.2 | P02 | S02 | 2 | 2-3 | not perfect: long tail, normal next linegap.
f111v.4 | P03 | S03 | 3 | 4-6 | not perfect: long prev, normal prev linegap.
f111v.7 | P04 | S04 | 3 | 7-9 | not perfect: long tail, normal next linegap.
f111v.10 | P05 | S05 | 3 | 10-12 | not perfect: long prev, normal prev linegap.
f111v.13 | P06 | S06 | 3 | 13-15 | not perfect: long tail, normal next linegap.
f111v.16 | P07 | S07 | 2 | 16-17 | not perfect: long prev, normal prev linegap, long tail, normal next linegap.
f111v.18 | P08 | S08 | 2 | 18-19 | not perfect: long prev, normal prev linegap.
f111v.20 | P09 | S09 | 4 | 20-23 | PERFECT.
f111v.24 | P10 | S10 | 2 | 24-25 | PERFECT.
f111v.26 | P11 | S11 | 3 | 26-28 | PERFECT.
f111v.29 | P12 | S12 | 2 | 29-30 | not perfect: long tail, normal next linegap.
f111v.31 | P13 | S13 | 1 | 31-31 | not perfect: long prev, normal prev linegap, long tail, normal next linegap.
f111v.32 | P14 | S14 | 2 | 32-33 | not perfect: long prev, normal prev linegap.
f111v.34 | P15 | S15 | 3 | 34-36 | PERFECT.
f111v.37 | P16 | S16 | 2 | 37-38 | PERFECT.
f111v.39 | P17 | S17 | 6 | 39-44 | PERFECT.
f111v.45 | P18 | S18 | 3 | 45-47 | PERFECT.
f111v.48 | P19 | S19 | 4 | 48-51 | PERFECT.
PAGE | STR | SHL | PUF | XPF | XWL | PGH | TXL | PPG | PLN | IPG | ILN
f111v | 19 | 8 | 11 | 0 | 0 | 19 | 51 | 9 | 28 | 10 | 23
The vellum surface on the right side of f112r had a problem that prevented writing there. The first line is damaged and linegaps may have been affected as the Scribe tried to adapt to the situation.
The obvious breaks, because of short previous lines, are before lines 11, 15 19, 23, 27, 31, 34, 37, and 39.
These obvious breaks naturally define parags 11-14 (@tchedy, naturally assigned to S03), 15-18 (@poaralchar, S04), 19-22 (@polchedy, S05), 23-26 (@qoain, S06) 27-30(@pcholkeedy, S07), 31-33 (@pairal, S08), 34-36 (@pairar, S09), and 37-38 (@pamokaiin, S10).
Line 23 starts with a very crooked handwriting, then after the unusual word @dairiy the baseline jumps up by more than 1 oht, and continues with more normal handwriting.
Star S09 is actually halfway between 32 and 33, but 33 is the short line, not 32.
These assignments leave unsplit the blocks 1-10 (with S01 and unassigned S02) and 39-45 (S11 and unassigned S12).
Among lines 1-10 of f112r, line 4 is shorter than the neighbors by 2 glyphs and ends in @m, and the linegap 4-5 is wider on the left side.
Thus we broke before line 5; which is aligned with S02, and hence assigned to it. That defines parags 1-4 (@polchey, S01) and 5-10 (@otair, S02)
Among lines 39-45 of f112r, line 40 is shorter than line 41 by 2.5 glyphs, but is just as long as line 39. Each of ines 42 and 43 is shorter than the line below by 0.5, but longer than the line above. Line 44 is shorter than 43 by 1.0, but it must be because the vellum was bad. So the line lengths are not useful.
On the other hand the linegap 41-42 is significantly wider overall, and line 42 starts with a puff. Thus the almost-obvious break is before line 42, which is aligned with S12 and hence assigned to it.
That choice defines parags 39-41 (@palkeedy, S11) and 42-45 (@palar, S12).
PAGE ! SNN ! VPOS ! CORE ! PAINT ! CLR ! R ! T ! OBS
------+-----+------+------+-------+-----+---+---+---------------
f112r | S01 | 00.7 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f112r | S02 | 05.0 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f112r | S03 | 11.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f112r | S04 | 15.0 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f112r | S05 | 19.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f112r | S06 | 23.0 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f112r | S07 | 27.0 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | 1 | --
f112r | S08 | 31.0 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f112r | S09 | 32.5 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f112r | S10 | 36.5 | dot | splot | yel | 8 | 1 | --
f112r | S11 | 39.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f112r | S12 | 42.0 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
PLOC | PNN | SNN | NL | LRANGE | EVALUATION.
f112r.1 | P01 | S01 | 4 | 1-4 | PERFECT.
f112r.5 | P02 | S02 | 6 | 5-10 | PERFECT.
f112r.11 | P03 | S03 | 4 | 11-14 | PERFECT.
f112r.15 | P04 | S04 | 4 | 15-18 | PERFECT.
f112r.19 | P05 | S05 | 4 | 19-22 | PERFECT.
f112r.23 | P06 | S06 | 4 | 23-26 | PERFECT.
f112r.27 | P07 | S07 | 4 | 27-30 | PERFECT.
f112r.31 | P08 | S08 | 3 | 31-33 | PERFECT.
f112r.34 | P09 | S09 | 3 | 34-36 | not perfect: body puffs.
f112r.37 | P10 | S10 | 2 | 37-38 | PERFECT.
f112r.39 | P11 | S11 | 3 | 39-41 | PERFECT.
f112r.42 | P12 | S12 | 4 | 42-45 | not perfect: body puffs.
PAGE | STR | SHL | PUF | XPF | XWL | PGH | TXL | PPG | PLN | IPG | ILN
f112r | 12 | 11 | 12 | 2 | 0 | 12 | 45 | 10 | 38 | 2 | 7
The stars of f112v lie roughly on a straight line but that line is significantly tilted, apparently to avoid some area of bad parch at the top left corner, adjacent to the big indentation on the edge. That hypothesis is suported by the tilt and two steps of indentation of the left rail of the text. Perhaps the parch in that part was oily and did not hold the ink?
The obvious parag breaks on f112v, because of short lines, are before lines 7 (@pchykeey), 11 (@tchor), 15 (@pchodain), 20 (@pchoraiin), 23 (@ycheol), 25 (@pchdaiin), 27 (@pchodain), 30 (@polar), 32 (@tchedor), 35 (@pched), 36 (@tchede), 39 (@teodarody), 42 (@poly), and 45 (@ycheey).
Star S01 is halfway between lines 1 and 2, and line 1 is a bit short and ends in @am. Thus it may be that line 1 is a title, or continuation of the last parag of f112r. However line 1 has two puffs, while line 2 has none. So we ignore this possibility and put a break before line 1 (@teeoal) with starlet S02.
Star S02 is aligned with line 6, but the obvious head line is line 7 (@pchykeey), so it is assigned there.
Line 25 is a rather an obvious parag break, and even starts with a puff, but it does not have a star nearby. But that the previous line 24 is only 4 glyphs short. Perhaps the Scribe did not see it, and omitted the star by mistake?
Line 35 is the same situation. It is very short itself, but it too starts with a puff and the prev line too is short by 4 glyphs.
Star S11 is halfway between lines 38 and 39, but 38 is short, so we assign S11 to the obvious headline 39 (@teodarody).
All the other stars are aligned with the other obvious breaks above. These breaks completely split the page into 15 parags, two of them without starlets.
Lines 43 and 44 contain two puffs each, while the designated head line 42 has none. It is possible that one or both of them are head lines (without starlets) too. We ignored that possibility for now.
PAGE ! SNN ! VPOS ! CORE ! PAINT ! CLR ! R ! T ! OBS
------+-----+------+------+-------+-----+---+---+---------------
f112v | S01 | 01.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f112v | S02 | 07.9 | no? | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | very_faint
f112v | S03 | 11.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 2 | --
f112v | S04 | 15.0 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f112v | S05 | 20.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f112v | S06 | 23.2 | ring | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | ray_stub
f112v | S07 | 27.0 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | 1 | --
f112v | S08 | 30.0 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f112v | S09 | 32.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f112v | S10 | 36.0 | no | splot | yel | 8 | 2 | --
f112v | S11 | 38.5 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f112v | S12 | 42.0 | no | splot | yel | 6 | 1 | --
f112v | S13 | 45.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
PLOC | PNN | SNN | NL | LRANGE | EVALUATION.
f112v.1 | P01 | S01 | 6 | 1-6 | PERFECT.
f112v.7 | P02 | S02 | 4 | 7-10 | PERFECT.
f112v.11 | P03 | S03 | 4 | 11-14 | PERFECT.
f112v.15 | P04 | S04 | 5 | 15-19 | PERFECT.
f112v.20 | P05 | S05 | 3 | 20-22 | PERFECT.
f112v.23 | P06 | S06 | 2 | 23-24 | PERFECT.
f112v.25 | P07 | NoS | 2 | 25-26 | not perfect: no starlet.
f112v.27 | P08 | S07 | 3 | 27-29 | PERFECT.
f112v.30 | P09 | S08 | 2 | 30-31 | PERFECT.
f112v.32 | P10 | S09 | 3 | 32-34 | PERFECT.
f112v.35 | P11 | NoS | 1 | 35-35 | not perfect: no starlet.
f112v.36 | P12 | S10 | 3 | 36-38 | PERFECT.
f112v.39 | P13 | S11 | 3 | 39-41 | PERFECT.
f112v.42 | P14 | S12 | 3 | 42-44 | not perfect: internal wide linegap, body puffs.
f112v.45 | P15 | S13 | 3 | 45-47 | PERFECT.
PAGE | STR | SHL | PUF | XPF | XWL | PGH | TXL | PPG | PLN | IPG | ILN
f112v | 13 | 15 | 13 | 2 | 1 | 15 | 47 | 12 | 41 | 3 | 6
Stars on f113r lie rather close to the binding edge and are distorted in scans by the curvature of the parch there.
The obvious parag breaks on f113r, because they follow short lines, are before lines 1 (@pches?chy, S01) 4 (@kcheeos, star S02 at line 03.5), 8 (@pchosos, S03 @ 7.5), 10 (@pcheody, S04 at 10.2), 13 (@polchos, S05), 16 (@pcheoor, S06), 20 (@ksharaiin, S07), 22 (@tchoar, S08 at 22.5), 25 (@pchodair, no star), 27 (@tchol, S09), 30 (@folchsar, S10) 34 (@palchsar, S11), 37 (@tshedy, S12), 39 (@pcheockhy, S13), 42 (@pchodaiin,S14 at 42.5), and 45 (tchodairos, S15).
Those 15 breaks define 14 parags, all perfect except for 22-24 that has a puff on the tail line, and 25-26 which begins with a puff but has no star.
There are no obvious breaks in lines 45-51, but there is one unassigned star (S16) at lines 48.5. The linegaps 47-48 and 48-49 are slightly wider than normal near the right rail. The baseline of line 49 is more parallel to that of line 49 than that of line 47. Line 47 ends with @am. So we decided to break before line 48, and assign S16 to it.
PAGE ! SNN ! VPOS ! CORE ! PAINT ! CLR ! R ! T ! OBS
------+-----+------+------+-------+-----+---+---+---------------
f113r | S01 | 01.0 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f113r | S02 | 03.5 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f113r | S03 | 07.5 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f113r | S04 | 10.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f113r | S05 | 13.0 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f113r | S06 | 16.0 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | 1 | --
f113r | S07 | 20.0 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f113r | S08 | 22.7 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | 1 | --
f113r | S09 | 27.0 | no | splot | yel | 8 | 1 | --
f113r | S10 | 30.3 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f113r | S11 | 34.0 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f113r | S12 | 37.0 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | 1 | --
f113r | S13 | 39.0 | no | splot | yel | 8 | 2 | --
f113r | S14 | 42.2 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | grushish
f113r | S15 | 45.0 | no | fill | yel | 8 | 1 | --
f113r | S16 | 48.5 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | 1 | --
PLOC | PNN | SNN | NL | LRANGE | EVALUATION.
f113r.1 | P01 | S01 | 3 | 1-3 | PERFECT.
f113r.4 | P02 | S02 | 4 | 4-7 | PERFECT.
f113r.8 | P03 | S03 | 2 | 8-9 | PERFECT.
f113r.10 | P04 | S04 | 3 | 10-12 | PERFECT.
f113r.13 | P05 | S05 | 3 | 13-15 | PERFECT.
f113r.16 | P06 | S06 | 4 | 16-19 | PERFECT.
f113r.20 | P07 | S07 | 2 | 20-21 | PERFECT.
f113r.22 | P08 | S08 | 3 | 22-24 | not perfect: internal wide linegap, body puffs.
f113r.25 | P09 | NoS | 2 | 25-26 | not perfect: no starlet.
f113r.27 | P10 | S09 | 3 | 27-29 | PERFECT.
f113r.30 | P11 | S10 | 4 | 30-33 | PERFECT.
f113r.34 | P12 | S11 | 3 | 34-36 | PERFECT.
f113r.37 | P13 | S12 | 2 | 37-38 | PERFECT.
f113r.39 | P14 | S13 | 3 | 39-41 | PERFECT.
f113r.42 | P15 | S14 | 3 | 42-44 | PERFECT.
f113r.45 | P16 | S15 | 3 | 45-47 | not perfect: long tail, normal next linegap.
f113r.48 | P17 | S16 | 4 | 48-51 | not perfect: long prev, normal prev linegap.
PAGE | STR | SHL | PUF | XPF | XWL | PGH | TXL | PPG | PLN | IPG | ILN
f113r | 16 | 16 | 15 | 1 | 1 | 17 | 51 | 13 | 39 | 4 | 12
The obvious parag breaks on f113v, after short lines, are at lines 1 (@folorarom, S01 at line 0.7), 4 (@fchoctheody, S02), 7 (@fcheshd, S03 at 6.7), 10 (@polaiin, S04), 13 (@poraiin,S05), 18 (@pychdar, S06 at 17.5), 21 (@polaiin, S07 at 20.7), 25 (@tokary, S08), 28 (@paiir, S09), 33 (@palrairy, S10), 36 (S11, ofaral), 38 (@pcholky, S12), 42 (@pol.keeody, S13 at 41.7) 45 (@polaiin.arol S14), and 47 (@polaiin.ksheeol, S15).
These 15 break split the page into 15 parags, all perfect except for 13-17 (5 lines) that has a puff on line 15. Thus maybe there is a break before line 15, making 15-17 into a parag without starlet. But the situation is confusing; line 14 has the unusual ending @olo, and line 15 contains two weirdos and ends in @am. Better leave it unsplit, but exclude it from analyses.
PAGE ! SNN ! VPOS ! CORE ! PAINT ! CLR ! R ! T ! OBS
------+-----+------+------+-------+-----+---+---+---------------
f113v | S01 | 01.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f113v | S02 | 04.0 | no | splot | yel | 8 | 1 | --
f113v | S03 | 07.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f113v | S04 | 10.0 | dot | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f113v | S05 | 13.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f113v | S06 | 18.0 | dot | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f113v | S07 | 21.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f113v | S08 | 25.0 | dot | splot | yel | 8 | 1 | --
f113v | S09 | 28.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f113v | S10 | 33.0 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f113v | S11 | 36.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f113v | S12 | 38.0 | dot | splot | yel | 8 | 1 | --
f113v | S13 | 42.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f113v | S14 | 45.0 | no | splot | yel | 8 | 1 | --
f113v | S15 | 47.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
PLOC | PNN | SNN | NL | LRANGE | EVALUATION.
f113v.1 | P01 | S01 | 3 | 1-3 | PERFECT.
f113v.4 | P02 | S02 | 3 | 4-6 | PERFECT.
f113v.7 | P03 | S03 | 3 | 7-9 | PERFECT.
f113v.10 | P04 | S04 | 3 | 10-12 | PERFECT.
f113v.13 | P05 | S05 | 5 | 13-17 | not perfect: body puffs.
f113v.18 | P06 | S06 | 3 | 18-20 | PERFECT.
f113v.21 | P07 | S07 | 4 | 21-24 | PERFECT.
f113v.25 | P08 | S08 | 3 | 25-27 | PERFECT.
f113v.28 | P09 | S09 | 5 | 28-32 | PERFECT.
f113v.33 | P10 | S10 | 3 | 33-35 | PERFECT.
f113v.36 | P11 | S11 | 2 | 36-37 | PERFECT.
f113v.38 | P12 | S12 | 4 | 38-41 | PERFECT.
f113v.42 | P13 | S13 | 3 | 42-44 | PERFECT.
f113v.45 | P14 | S14 | 2 | 45-46 | PERFECT.
f113v.47 | P15 | S15 | 3 | 47-49 | PERFECT.
PAGE | STR | SHL | PUF | XPF | XWL | PGH | TXL | PPG | PLN | IPG | ILN
f113v | 15 | 15 | 16 | 1 | 0 | 15 | 49 | 14 | 44 | 1 | 5
On f114r, the obvious breaks (after short lines) are on line 1 (@tchedol, with star S01), 4 (@fdeechdy, S02 at 4.2), 8 (@fchey.dam, S03), 11 (@dalcy, S04), 14 (@solpchd, S05 at 14.5), 19 (@pairody, S06), 22 (@tchedair, S07), 24 (@tchedaiin, S08 at 25.0), 28 (@pchedairs, S09 at 18.5), 32 (@tcheodaiin, S10 at 31.5), 35 (@pcheos, S11 at 33.5), and 39 (@todaiin, S12 at 38.1).
Line 34 is right-justified and only half a page wide. Some consider it a title, but it is possible (likely?) that it is a part of one of the two adjacent parags. In the "U" transcription it is considered the tail of the previous parag. But the the block of lines 32-38 should be considered suspicious and excluded from sensitive analyses.
The breaks above define 12 parags, all perfect except for 32-34 because of the right-justified tail. It leaves lines 39-45 unsplit, with a starlet S12 assigned to line 39 and star S13 unassigned.
Lines 39-44 are all long. However there is a wide linegap before line 42, which starts with a puff and has two other puffs. There is a sly wide linegap 40-41 but it does not compare tp 41-42. So w e break before line 42 and assign S13 to it. But maybe we should exclude 39-45 from analyses, too. Or maybe that is too much precaution...
PAGE ! SNN ! VPOS ! CORE ! PAINT ! CLR ! R ! T ! OBS
------+-----+------+------+-------+-----+---+---+---------------
f114r | S01 | 01.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f114r | S02 | 04.0 | no | splot | yel | 8 | 2 | --
f114r | S03 | 08.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f114r | S04 | 11.0 | no | splot | yel | 8 | 1 | --
f114r | S05 | 14.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f114r | S06 | 19.0 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f114r | S07 | 22.2 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f114r | S08 | 25.0 | no | splot | yel | 8 | 2 | --
f114r | S09 | 28.5 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f114r | S10 | 32.0 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f114r | S11 | 34.8 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | 1 | --
f114r | S12 | 38.1 | no | splot | yel | 8 | 1 | --
f114r | S13 | 41.3 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | 1 | --
PLOC | PNN | SNN | NL | LRANGE | EVALUATION.
f114r.1 | P01 | S01 | 3 | 1-3 | PERFECT.
f114r.4 | P02 | S02 | 4 | 4-7 | PERFECT.
f114r.8 | P03 | S03 | 3 | 8-10 | PERFECT.
f114r.11 | P04 | S04 | 3 | 11-13 | PERFECT.
f114r.14 | P05 | S05 | 5 | 14-18 | PERFECT.
f114r.19 | P06 | S06 | 3 | 19-21 | PERFECT.
f114r.22 | P07 | S07 | 2 | 22-23 | PERFECT.
f114r.24 | P08 | S08 | 4 | 24-27 | PERFECT.
f114r.28 | P09 | S09 | 4 | 28-31 | PERFECT.
f114r.32 | P10 | S10 | 3 | 32-34 | not perfect: indented line.
f114r.35 | P11 | S11 | 4 | 35-38 | PERFECT.
f114r.39 | P12 | S12 | 3 | 39-41 | not perfect: internal wide linegap.
f114r.42 | P13 | S13 | 4 | 42-45 | not perfect: body puffs.
PAGE | STR | SHL | PUF | XPF | XWL | PGH | TXL | PPG | PLN | IPG | ILN
f114r | 13 | 12 | 13 | 1 | 1 | 13 | 45 | 10 | 35 | 3 | 10
On f114v, the obvious parag breaks (after short lines) are before lines 1 (@pchdol, S01), 6 (@tedcheo, S02 at 5.5), 11 (@tchedy, S04 at 10.8), 14 (@tsheodar, S05 at 13.6), 18 (@dorkcheky, S06), 20 (@tshedain, S07 at 20.5), 23 (@pshedy, S08 at 22.5), 26 (@pcheodal, S09 at 25.5), 29 (@pchdair, S10), 33 (@kaiin, S11 at 32.7), and 36 (@tshey, S12 at 35.7).
These breaks define a parag with lines 1-5 and starlet S01, and 9 perfect parags spanning lines 11-41 with starlet S04-S12, all perfect. They leave unsplit the block of lines 6-10 with starlet S02 assigned to line 6 and star S03 unassigned.
While lines 6-9 are all long, the linegap 7-8 is significantly wider at the left side; also line 8 starts with a puff and is aligned with star S03. So we break before line 8 and assign starlet S03 to it.
The last parag 36-41 is rather long (6 lines) and this page has only 12 stars, or 2.5 less than average. The linegap 38-39 is sly wider at right. Maybe there should be a break before 39 but the Scribe forgot the last star because the previous tail line 38 came out long.
PAGE ! SNN ! VPOS ! CORE ! PAINT ! CLR ! R ! T ! OBS
------+-----+------+------+-------+-----+---+---+---------------
f114v | S01 | 01.0 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f114v | S02 | 05.3 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f114v | S03 | 08.0 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f114v | S04 | 11.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f114v | S05 | 14.0 | no | splot | yel | 8 | 2 | grafted_ray
f114v | S06 | 18.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 2 | --
f114v | S07 | 20.4 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 2 | --
f114v | S08 | 22.7 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f114v | S09 | 25.6 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 1 | --
f114v | S10 | 29.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f114v | S11 | 33.0 | no | splot | yel | 7 | 2 | --
f114v | S12 | 35.7 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | 1 | --
PLOC | PNN | SNN | NL | LRANGE | EVALUATION.
f114v.1 | P01 | S01 | 5 | 1-5 | PERFECT.
f114v.6 | P02 | S02 | 2 | 6-7 | PERFECT.
f114v.8 | P03 | S03 | 3 | 8-10 | PERFECT.
f114v.11 | P04 | S04 | 3 | 11-13 | PERFECT.
f114v.14 | P05 | S05 | 4 | 14-17 | PERFECT.
f114v.18 | P06 | S06 | 2 | 18-19 | PERFECT.
f114v.20 | P07 | S07 | 3 | 20-22 | PERFECT.
f114v.23 | P08 | S08 | 3 | 23-25 | PERFECT.
f114v.26 | P09 | S09 | 3 | 26-28 | PERFECT.
f114v.29 | P10 | S10 | 4 | 29-32 | PERFECT.
f114v.33 | P11 | S11 | 3 | 33-35 | PERFECT.
f114v.36 | P12 | S12 | 6 | 36-41 | not perfect: internal wide linegap.
PAGE | STR | SHL | PUF | XPF | XWL | PGH | TXL | PPG | PLN | IPG | ILN
f114v | 12 | 11 | 10 | 0 | 1 | 12 | 41 | 11 | 35 | 1 | 6
The obvious parag breaks on f115r, after short lines, are before line 1 (@pshhdar, with star S01 at line 1.2), 4 (@dchedain, S02 at 3.5), 8 (@kcheor, S03 at 7.5), 10 (@tchedy.kechedy, S04 at 9.8), 13 (@tchedy.qoolkeedy, S05 at 12.5), 19 (@pcheodain, S06 at 18.2), 22 (@pcheody, S07), 26 (@ksheoary, S08), 29 (@fshedy, S09 at 29.2), 35 (@poshos, S10 at 34.5), 37 (@sorols, S11 at 36.7), 40 (@paiinody, S12), and 42 (@tcheodl, S13).
These breaks define 13 parags and assign all the stars to them. They are all perfect, except 29-34 (6 lines) that has a puff in line 31. The linegap 30-31 is definitely wider in the left half. So maybe there should be a break before line 31, breaking that parag into 39-30 (2 lines) and 31-34 (4 lines) with no starlet. But there is no other hint supposting that break. Just keep that in mind...
There is another 6-line parag on f115r, namely 13-18. Lines 14 and 15 end in @m, but other than that there is no visible clue for a break there.
PAGE ! SNN ! VPOS ! CORE ! PAINT ! CLR ! R ! T ! OBS
------+-----+------+------+-------+-----+---+---+---------------
f115r | S01 | 01.2 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f115r | S02 | 04.0 | dot | splot | yel | 8 | - | --
f115r | S03 | 08.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f115r | S04 | 10.0 | no | splot | yel | 8 | 1 | wormhole
f115r | S05 | 13.0 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | 2 | filled_tail
f115r | S06 | 18.3 | -- | splot | RED | 9 | 1 | --
f115r | S07 | 22.2 | no | splot | yel | 8 | 1 | --
f115r | S08 | 26.0 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | 1 | --
f115r | S09 | 29.0 | no | splot | yel | 8 | 1 | --
f115r | S10 | 35.0 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | 1 | --
f115r | S11 | 37.0 | no | splot | yel | 8 | 1 | --
f115r | S12 | 40.0 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | 1 | --
f115r | S13 | 42.0 | no | splot | yel | 8 | 1 | --
PLOC | PNN | SNN | NL | LRANGE | EVALUATION.
f115r.1 | P01 | S01 | 3 | 1-3 | PERFECT.
f115r.4 | P02 | S02 | 4 | 4-7 | PERFECT.
f115r.8 | P03 | S03 | 2 | 8-9 | PERFECT.
f115r.10 | P04 | S04 | 3 | 10-12 | PERFECT.
f115r.13 | P05 | S05 | 6 | 13-18 | PERFECT.
f115r.19 | P06 | S06 | 3 | 19-21 | PERFECT.
f115r.22 | P07 | S07 | 4 | 22-25 | PERFECT.
f115r.26 | P08 | S08 | 3 | 26-28 | PERFECT.
f115r.29 | P09 | S09 | 6 | 29-34 | not perfect: body puffs.
f115r.35 | P10 | S10 | 2 | 35-36 | PERFECT.
f115r.37 | P11 | S11 | 3 | 37-39 | PERFECT.
f115r.40 | P12 | S12 | 2 | 40-41 | PERFECT.
f115r.42 | P13 | S13 | 4 | 42-45 | PERFECT.
PAGE | STR | SHL | PUF | XPF | XWL | PGH | TXL | PPG | PLN | IPG | ILN
f115r | 13 | 13 | 12 | 1 | 0 | 13 | 45 | 12 | 39 | 1 | 6
On f115v, the short lines determine obvious parag preaks before lines 1 (@tcheodor, with aligned star S01), 6 (@pchody, with star S02 at line 5.2), 8 (@tcheosos, S03 at 7.2), 11 (@tchedor, S04), 13 (@pchdarody, S05 at 13.3), 18 (@pchodain, S06 at 17.8), 21 (@tshedy, S07 at 10.8), 24 (@pcheo, S08 at 23.3), 29 (@polor, S09 at 28.0), 31 (@pchdair, S10 at 30.5), 34 (@taiin, S11 at 33.5), 37 (@tshar, S12 at 36.5), and 41 (@dcheodl, S13 at 40.5).
These breaks completey split the page (lines 1-45) into 13 parags, all with a starlet and all perfect. There are four 50 line parags: 1-5, 13-17, 24-28, qne 41-45. Only the last one has a hint that it may be two parags, namely the linegap 41-42 i wide on the right side. Also 42-43 is a bit wider in the midle-right area, and 42 ends in @m. But these hints are not strong enough to make us add a break without starlet.
PAGE ! SNN ! VPOS ! CORE ! PAINT ! CLR ! R ! T ! OBS
------+-----+------+------+-------+-----+---+---+---------------
f115v | S01 | 01.0 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | 1 | --
f115v | S02 | 05.1 | no | no | -- | 8 | 1 | --
f115v | S03 | 07.2 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | 1 | --
f115v | S04 | 11.0 | no | splot | WHT | 8 | 1 | --
f115v | S05 | 13.3 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | 1 | --
f115v | S06 | 18.0 | no | splot | WHT | 8 | 1 | --
f115v | S07 | 21.0 | -- | splot | RED | 9 | 1 | patch
f115v | S08 | 23.4 | no | no | -- | 8 | 1 | --
f115v | S09 | 28.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | 1 | --
f115v | S10 | 30.3 | no | no | -- | 7 | 1 | --
f115v | S11 | 34.0 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | 1 | --
f115v | S12 | 36.5 | dot | no | -- | 8 | 1 | --
f115v | S13 | 40.5 | -- | splot | RED | 8 | 1 | --
PLOC | PNN | SNN | NL | LRANGE | EVALUATION.
f115v.1 | P01 | S01 | 5 | 1-5 | PERFECT.
f115v.6 | P02 | S02 | 2 | 6-7 | PERFECT.
f115v.8 | P03 | S03 | 3 | 8-10 | PERFECT.
f115v.11 | P04 | S04 | 2 | 11-12 | PERFECT.
f115v.13 | P05 | S05 | 5 | 13-17 | PERFECT.
f115v.18 | P06 | S06 | 3 | 18-20 | PERFECT.
f115v.21 | P07 | S07 | 3 | 21-23 | PERFECT.
f115v.24 | P08 | S08 | 5 | 24-28 | PERFECT.
f115v.29 | P09 | S09 | 2 | 29-30 | PERFECT.
f115v.31 | P10 | S10 | 3 | 31-33 | PERFECT.
f115v.34 | P11 | S11 | 3 | 34-36 | PERFECT.
f115v.37 | P12 | S12 | 4 | 37-40 | PERFECT.
f115v.41 | P13 | S13 | 5 | 41-45 | PERFECT.
PAGE | STR | SHL | PUF | XPF | XWL | PGH | TXL | PPG | PLN | IPG | ILN
f115v | 13 | 13 | 11 | 0 | 0 | 13 | 45 | 13 | 45 | 0 | 0
On f116r there are obvious parag breaks before lines 1 (@kchdpy, with S01 aligned), 4 (@padar, with S02 at line 3.5), 7 (@pchol, S03 at 6.8), 10 (@chdain, S04), 15 (@pchoetal, S06), and 18 (@pcharalar, S07).
Breaking at those points and ssigning the stars as listed will create four perfect parags (1-3, 4-6, 7-9, and 16-17), leaving two unsplit blocks: 10-14 (with unassigned star S05), and 18-30 (with unassigned stars S08, S09, and S10).
As for the 10-14 block, lines 10, 12, and 13 end in @m. The only linegap that is significantly wide is 10-11. Lacking better clues we break before line 11 (@ol.aiin), creating a parag 11-14 with starlet S05, and line 10 alone as a parag with starlet S04. But these two parags should be excluded from any sensitive analysis.
As for the 18-30 block, all the lines 22-27 end in @m, so that gives no clue. The linegap 25-26 is wide on the right side, but 26-27 even wider, and line 27 has a puff. So we chose to break before 27 (@daiin), and assign star S10 (which is at 26.5) to it. That makes lines 27-30 into a parag, and leaves 18-26 to be split, with unassigned star S09.
(Something tells me that 26 would be the correct choice. Although it is possible that the break is in the middle of line 27.)
Finally, for the lack of better clues, we break before line 21 (@sairol) and assign S08 to it.
PAGE ! SNN ! VPOS ! CORE ! PAINT ! CLR ! R ! T ! OBS
------+-----+------+------+-------+-----+---+---+---------------
f116r | S01 | 01.0 | no | splot | yel | 7 | - | --
f116r | S02 | 04.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | - | --
f116r | S03 | 07.0 | no | splot | yel | 7 | - | --
f116r | S04 | 10.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | - | --
f116r | S05 | 12.9 | no | splot | yel | 8 | - | wormhole
f116r | S06 | 15.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | - | --
f116r | S07 | 18.0 | dot | splot | yel | 8 | - | small_chubby
f116r | S08 | 21.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | - | --
f116r | S09 | 24.0 | no | splot | yel | 8 | - | --
f116r | S10 | 27.0 | -- | splot | RED | 7 | - | --
PLOC | PNN | SNN | NL | LRANGE | EVALUATION.
f116r.1 | P01 | S01 | 3 | 1-3 | PERFECT.
f116r.4 | P02 | S02 | 3 | 4-6 | PERFECT.
f116r.7 | P03 | S03 | 3 | 7-9 | PERFECT.
f116r.10 | P04 | S04 | 1 | 10-10 | PERFECT.
f116r.11 | P05 | S05 | 4 | 11-14 | PERFECT.
f116r.15 | P06 | S06 | 3 | 15-17 | not perfect: body puffs.
f116r.18 | P07 | S07 | 3 | 18-20 | not perfect: long tail, normal next linegap, body puffs.
f116r.21 | P08 | S08 | 4 | 21-24 | not perfect: long prev, normal prev linegap.
f116r.25 | P09 | S09 | 2 | 25-26 | PERFECT.
f116r.27 | P10 | S10 | 4 | 27-30 | PERFECT.
PAGE | STR | SHL | PUF | XPF | XWL | PGH | TXL | PPG | PLN | IPG | ILN
f116r | 10 | 8 | 8 | 2 | 0 | 10 | 30 | 7 | 20 | 3 | 10
Last edited on 2026-02-09 23:06:23 by stolfi